The TRshady Forum became read-only in December 2014. The 10 year history will live on, in this archive.
Continue the discussion with the new home for the Eminem and Hip Hop discussion: HipHopShelter.com.

A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

All questions and discussions on Eminem to be found here.

A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby stillmatic » Feb 20th, '11, 02:46

There's always some people who say there's bias against Eminem because he's this or that, and they say his critics never give proper reasoning. Well, here's a review below which does.

It's Combat Jack, who's a pretty well known figure in NY hip hop and has been around for a long time, and has his own radio station and was the writer for popular hip hop blog site 'Daily Mathematics'.

It’s been five years since Eminem dropped his last lp “Encore”, which was at most… meh. His most recent venture “Relapse” found it’s way into my ipod today. Here’s my review:

“Dr. West (Intro)” – Great intro. Scenario is of Marshall getting “great” advice upon his rehab release from his therapist. Sets up the next song lovely.

“3am” – The sequencing between the last track and this is perfect. I like this here better after I watched the video. Did Dre produce this? Only because I’m not mad at the production. At all. Plus, I’m digging the “Silence of the Lambs” reference. The horns, the keys, that dramatic foreboding tone is all there. Classic Em and Dre (?).

“My Mom” – Nigga, you ain’t resolve any of those effin’ issues with your moms yet? Em shares with us how effd up his childhood was and how he claims his moms introduced Valium and all other types of shit to him through his food. Marshall, for real, work that shit out or kill her already. This topic is as tired as it is listening to 40 year Jay still rapping about moving weight. Don’t get me wrong, the song is somewhat decent, it’s just we’ve been there and done done that already. No typo. Several times. I am firmly convinced that I don’t ever wanna hear another song about Eminem’s mom ever ever ever again.

“Insane” – Whoah!!! Em’s rapping about how he was forced to suck on his uncle when he was a lil’ kid? TMI!!! Anyways, this gem is laced with a tired ass sounding Dr. Dre(?) track. On the 2nd and 3rd verses, Em ’s flow suddenly sounds like he’s B-Real of Cyprus Hills fame. Meh.

“Bagpipes From Baghdad” – This is dope. If it were 1999 again. For 2009, not so much. Oh, he’s dissing Mariah again? Why? Plus some shots at Nick Cannon. Dayum. Production sounds like an old Dr. Dre track. But not in a good way. Ah man. I don’t think I’m liking where this album is going.

“Hello” – A really meh song trying really really hard to be a meh strip club banger. It succeeds in doing so.

“Tonya” - Another meh song about Em as a serial killer stalking Tanya, Lindsay and Britney. Poor them. Poor me too. There is absolutely zero amount of connect going on between this song and me.

“We Made You” -… fast forward to the next song. And quick!

“Medicine Ball” – Pretty good song, disgusting visuals though. And not that good to steer this cd from the train wreck that I’m foreseeing in the near future. Oh yeah, he fires some more shots at Christopher Reeves, whose been dead for years. What’s the point?

“Paul (skit)” – Yet another skit with Em’s manager Paul Rosenberg complaining about Em’s choice of content and subject matter. He’s also telling Em that Christopher Reeves has been dead for years. I’m wondering was he also complaining to Em about how shitty this album is sounding.

“Stay Wide Awake” – Great, another song about murder, and with buzzaws. ZZZZZZZZZ and meh.

“Old Times Sake feat. Dr. Dre” Uhm………………………………..

You know what? I’m a grown ass man with four kids, a mortgage, a beautiful wife who is wishing I spent less time on the keyboards, a close family member whose facing a potential life threatening disease and all other types of real life issues to deal with. FUCKOUTTA HERE! I’m not going through with the rest of this effin album. Not without getting paid. FUCK THAT. I have better shit to get into, and I deserve way better than this. And so do you. Stay away from this bitch!

On the strength of what I’ve heard and as extra credit for Eminem successfully undergoing a successful rehab, “Relapse” gets a 2 salutes out of 5 Combat Jack salutes.
The New York Times - "Lloyd Banks may have stealthily become the most important rapper in New York".
User avatar
stillmatic
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1131
Joined: Nov 4th, '09, 10:17

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby Master Chief » Feb 20th, '11, 02:57

Dude's a complete idiot.
Image

Satirical Graphitical Productions.
User avatar
Master Chief
Role Model
Role Model
 
Posts: 3891
Joined: Dec 8th, '10, 23:38
Location: Where?
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby shadyboymez » Feb 20th, '11, 03:00

who writes a review for an album while hearing it for the first time?

FAIL
ahead of my time, in my prime, one of a kind, out of my mind
User avatar
shadyboymez
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1314
Joined: Dec 7th, '09, 05:32
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby VenomBlackViper » Feb 20th, '11, 03:13

A reviewer who can't be bothered to finish an album? I'm sure his credibility is through the roof.
Image
User avatar
VenomBlackViper
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 5426
Joined: Dec 13th, '10, 22:13
Location: Going Through The Grinder
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby shadyboymez » Feb 20th, '11, 03:17

if you want some good music reviews, though not strictly hip-hop but very good and in depth check out these websites

http://www.theneedledrop.com
http://www.velocitiesinmusic.com
ahead of my time, in my prime, one of a kind, out of my mind
User avatar
shadyboymez
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1314
Joined: Dec 7th, '09, 05:32
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby stillmatic » Feb 20th, '11, 03:19

venomblackviper wrote:A reviewer who can't be bothered to finish an album? I'm sure his credibility is through the roof.


He's not a music critic, and never has tried to make himself out to be one.

He reviewed that as a fan of hip hop, when Eminem made his comeback and everyone was asking for him to do a review for his album.

Fwiw. I don't agree with his review, but CJ has crazy credibility in hip hop circles. There wouldn't be a rapper out there (excluding the really new generation) that wouldn't not know who he is.
The New York Times - "Lloyd Banks may have stealthily become the most important rapper in New York".
User avatar
stillmatic
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1131
Joined: Nov 4th, '09, 10:17

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby Kez » Feb 20th, '11, 04:01

These threads are way too predictable lol
User avatar
Kez
Pill Popper
Pill Popper
 
Posts: 8713
Joined: Jun 1st, '06, 20:04
Location: Japan
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby EminemInsider » Feb 20th, '11, 04:49

Encore, "at best," is the worst album in the history of mankind. He loses all credibility by hinting that it could be even called, "meh."
Canning: What will it say on your tombstone?
Charlie Sheen: Something dot com.

Canibus & Eminem Converse: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWB62t2_wJE
EminemInsider
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1197
Joined: Nov 15th, '08, 04:17

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby BigBangBazinga » Feb 20th, '11, 14:47

venomblackviper wrote:A reviewer who can't be bothered to finish an album? I'm sure his credibility is through the roof.
I'ma be BALLIN UNCONTROLLABLY

Have you guys ever rapped along with Almost Famous? You cant deny, its fun LOL. - Miller1121

we stans listen to Eminem like 12 hrs or when ever our eyes are open. :coffee:
. - MCSam
User avatar
BigBangBazinga
Role Model
Role Model
 
Posts: 3274
Joined: Sep 16th, '05, 12:30
Location: Sweden
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby classthe_king » Feb 20th, '11, 17:13

I didn't think that review was too off. And lol @ everyone getting mad, he said he wasn't even getting paid for this so he isn't obliged to do anything. Quit hating.
You think your personal attacks make up for what you lack?
User avatar
classthe_king
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 14163
Joined: Feb 12th, '09, 02:30
Location: Ohio
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby extremerecovery » Feb 20th, '11, 20:52

I've read reviews from this guy... he's a mad Biggie stan and was hating on 2Pac quite a few years back saying Pac was mad overrated :facepalm

Fuck him
User avatar
extremerecovery
Closet Cleaner
Closet Cleaner
 
Posts: 7
Joined: Feb 19th, '11, 12:00
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby EminemBase » Feb 20th, '11, 21:33

Awful review.

Don't care who he is, really lazy. Did he even listen or just skim through it.

Calling skits songs too lmao.
User avatar
EminemBase
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 10007
Joined: Dec 10th, '09, 06:37
Location: Inside your mind famalamalamalam.
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby One Mic » Feb 20th, '11, 21:45

It's a badly written and structured review, but the gist of what he is saying is true; Relapse sucks.

Recovery was an amazing comeback after the Relapse dissapointment.
One Mic
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1945
Joined: Nov 1st, '10, 11:47
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby BigBangBazinga » Feb 20th, '11, 21:51

EminemBase wrote:Awful review.

Don't care who he is, really lazy. Did he even listen or just skim through it.

Calling skits songs too lmao.



And he calls Same Song & Dance "Tonya" lol


One Mic: You probably think Infinite is Em's best album. :whistle:
I'ma be BALLIN UNCONTROLLABLY

Have you guys ever rapped along with Almost Famous? You cant deny, its fun LOL. - Miller1121

we stans listen to Eminem like 12 hrs or when ever our eyes are open. :coffee:
. - MCSam
User avatar
BigBangBazinga
Role Model
Role Model
 
Posts: 3274
Joined: Sep 16th, '05, 12:30
Location: Sweden
Gender: Male

Re: A hip hop traditionalists review of Relapse

Postby One Mic » Feb 20th, '11, 21:58

^ Nah

I literally can't decide out of SSLP, MMLP & TES (they are definitely top 3, but what order?)

Then Recovery, then Encore, then Relapse.
One Mic
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1945
Joined: Nov 1st, '10, 11:47
Gender: Male

Next

Return to Eminem



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users

cron