We were robbed from the perfect album

[slimshadylappin]

As we all know Em made three solo songs for his 8 Mile soundtrack. All three were undeniable classics.
Now imagine if he made the whole album. If he spent a lot of time and created the whole soundtrack by himself I believe this would blow any other Eminem album out of the water.

Discuss

[FreeSpeech]

As we all know Em made three solo songs for his 8 Mile soundtrack. All three were undeniable classics.
Now imagine if he made the whole album. If he spent a lot of time and created the whole soundtrack by himself I believe this would blow any other Eminem album out of the water.

Discuss

That album's called The Eminem Show moron, they dropped the same year...

[slimshadylappin]

As we all know Em made three solo songs for his 8 Mile soundtrack. All three were undeniable classics.
Now imagine if he made the whole album. If he spent a lot of time and created the whole soundtrack by himself I believe this would blow any other Eminem album out of the water.

Discuss

That album's called The Eminem Show moron, they dropped the same year...

NO using the concept of 8 Mile. Im not talking about the songs he made in that year for The Eminem Show.
I am talking about him making a whole album with the 8 Mile concept

[xxTrigger1989xx]

An entire album with the 8 Mile concept would have been the best album ever.

[FreeSpeech]

Gotcha, I misunderstood. That's still not really realistic, you can't focus on one concept for an entire album, he'd run out of different songs. Just appreciate it for what it was.

[rinnie1207]

That would have been amazing

But I'm happy with the 3 songs we did get and I don't think we were robbed. Out of the three Rabbit Run is my favorite.

[shadybaby46]

Gotcha, I misunderstood. That's still not really realistic, you can't focus on one concept for an entire album, he'd run out of different songs. Just appreciate it for what it was.

lol @ this guy.
are you the album creation police or something? since when can't you have an entire album with one concept? ESPECIALLY when it's a soundtrack for a movie?

[FreeSpeech]

Gotcha, I misunderstood. That's still not really realistic, you can't focus on one concept for an entire album, he'd run out of different songs. Just appreciate it for what it was.

lol @ this guy.
are you the album creation police or something? since when can't you have an entire album with one concept? ESPECIALLY when it's a soundtrack for a movie?

I'm just saying, artistically speaking, every track can't be a motivational hard hitting song like LY, Rabbit Run, and 8 Mile. I mean, it can, but the album would have very little depth or diversity. Basically, I can 100% see why Em didn't do it. Also, having an album full of those kind of tracks would make the 3 awesome ones we got less special.


^There's some facepalms to make my opinion more valid.

[Kez]

I do have to wonder if it's possible to actually make a whole album based on 8 Mile, and whether or not it'd just be a bunch of songs which are similiar to the 3 already made. After all, the 3 that he made for it were really all about the same thing, as great as they are.

[mdemaz]

It's funny how Em dropped 'TES,' made a movie then recorded a few tracks for the soundtrack and won a grammy for 'LY' in the same year..

[dshady89]

It's funny how Em dropped 'TES,' made a movie then recorded a few tracks for the soundtrack and won a grammy for 'LY' in the same year..

He was robbed for Song of the year though.

[mdemaz]

No doubt..

[slimsoxshady]

+ Rap Game
+ Love Me

[Mxracer6y]

That album's called The Eminem Show moron, they dropped the same year...

dude....


you're an idiot.

[Slill_Slim_Shady]

Nope, I don't think it would've been perfect. There's a couple things on the song "8 Mile Road" that I wish I had went back and fixed but what's done is done. I don't think any album I've made has been perfect.