EminemBase wrote:There's definitely some of that.
I wouldn't like to use that as an excuse for a bad review but some of the critics make it so obvious. They're so lame and bad at hiding it.
Yeah, I think you can definitely tell the difference between a review that really looks at the songs and finds them wanting and someone just using the review to restate his/her own prejudices. Some of the stuff that was written about his first three albums was just embarassing: Practically nothing about the music, only about what a "Bad Role Model" he is. Because that's what art should be about, squeaky clean feel good messages that don't ever question anything.
And then many people just really don't get it. This is what Slant Magazine had to say about TES:
http://www.slantmagazine.com/music/review/eminem-the-eminem-show/64At times, Eminem speaks for anyone who didn't blindly wave the stars and stripes in the wake of 9/11. On the scathing "White America," he defiantly vows to "spit liquor in the face of this democracy of hypocrisy" (though he unfortunately ends the track with a safe apologia)
It's a positive review, the writer mostly praises the album. But ultimately it's rather useless anyway, isn't it? I mean, is his irony and sarcasm really that hard to spot? Or is it because he's perceived as "trailer trash" that many won't admit how smart and complex the stuff he does is?
Look at the current praise orgy for Kanye West. It's a really good album IMO and I don't begrudge him the acclaim, but I'm sure that the hipster demographic feels comfortable embracing him at least partly because his presentation practically screams "Look at me! I'm a very important artist doing very serious artistic things!". Where are all the complaints about his depiction of women? See, when he does it it's "artistic", when Steely Dan write about pedophilia, it's "artistic", when Eminem does it, he must mean it literally, oh my god, won't anybody think of the children!!! Bah. Hypocrisy in its purest form.