Top Ten Em Songs All Time

[Ottawa613]

Sing for the Moment
Stan
Lose Yourself
Til' I Collapse
Deja Vu
Still Don't Give a Fuck
Rock Bottom
The Way I Am
Criminal
Kim

No order.

[DogManX]

Sing For The Moment
The Way I Am
Lose Yourself
Rock Bottom
Bad Guy
Stan
Still Don't Give A Fuck
Marshall Mathers
Brain Damage
Just Don't Give A Fuck

[Jimmy Conway]

I'm not even going to read this thread.

Let me guess a bunch of people putting MMLP2 songs way too high on the list because it's new and they're excited

[Hamza1972]

Sing For The Moment
Lose Yourself
Without Me
Stan
Deja Vu
You're Never Over
Going Through Changes
Rhyme Or Reason
Bad Guy
The Way I Am

[Cube23]

First 9 are always the same for me

1. Kim
2. Sing For The Moment
3. Say Goodbye Hollywood
4. Stan
5. Lose Yourself
6. The Way I Am
7. Kill You
8. Rock Bottom
9. Criminal
10. '97 Bonnie & Clyde/Till I Collapse

[trentimus]

I'm not even going to read this thread.

Let me guess a bunch of people putting MMLP2 songs way too high on the list because it's new and they're excited

Yes.

[kpprasa]

I'm not even going to read this thread.

Let me guess a bunch of people putting MMLP2 songs way too high on the list because it's new and they're excited

Yes.

Perhaps, but I'll change my opinion as the songs set in. My guess, is that maybe 1-2 MMLP2 in the final list. But this is mine right now.

[Wreck]

In no order, my list:

01. Lose Yourself
02. Stan
03. Rock Bottom
04. Beautiful
05. Sing For The Moment
06. Headlights
07. The Way I Am
08. Cleanin' out my Closet
09. 'Til I Collapse
10. 8 Mile Road

Notables (among others):

Guilty Conscience
Marshall Mathers
As The World Turns
Saying Goodbye to Hollywood
Bad Meets Evil
Kill You

I'm not even going to read this thread.

Let me guess a bunch of people putting MMLP2 songs way too high on the list because it's new and they're excited

I'd rather that I think, than the stupid assholes who think Relapse is the greatest Em album, or album period, ever. But yeah, I agree with you. I think Headlights is the only MMLP2 song worthy of the top 10 all-time songs list.

[Mathers]

Lose Yourself
Stan
8 Mile Road
Till I Collapse
Role Model
Criminal
Sing For The Moment
Marshall Mathers
Square Dance
Rock Bottom

[EminemBase]

"Bad Guy" made it but "Stan" didn't?

Seriously, I just listened to "Stan" and "Criminal" earlier... people who say MMLP2 > 1 or like it's even close are out of their MINDS.

MMLP2 is a great album but OH MY GOD. It's just not even close. "Stan" is still a masterpiece, and he will always lack that power unless he acts out the characters properly again... and "Criminal" is just fucking unreal; his wit and the free-psychosis nature and creativity of his rhymes and flow is absolutely out of this world, even now.

[EminemBase]

1. Stan
2. Bad Guy
3. Sing for the Moment
4. Headlights
5. Lose Yourself
6. Kim
7. Deja Vu
8. Criminal
9. Rabbit Run
10. (tie) I'm Back / White America

(Apologies to Charlotte and the other mods -- I didn't scroll down far enough to see this thread before replying to the other thread. )

Really @ "Headlights" @ top 10?... I find that so odd. Shit is a good track but nothing which compares to Em's best work.

[BILI]

Nice list! Imagine an album with THIS as the tracklist

1.The Way I am
2.Sing for the Moment
3.Stan
4.Bad Guy
5.Til I collapse
6.Lose Yourself
7.White America
8.Who Knew
9.Drug Balled
10.Brainless
11.Legacy
12.Lose Yourself
13.Soldier
14.Cleaning Out My Closet
15.Headlights
16.As The Worlds Turns
17.Just dont give a fuck
18.Still dont give a fuck
19.Evil Twin
20.Ken Kaniff (this would be a new recording of course)

Now THAT'S a greatest hits

This would be great but put Stan as 1st song and Bad Guy as last...damnnnnn

[Lost Myself]

Lose Yourself
Sing For the Moment
No Love
Underground
Stan
Bad Guy
Going Through Changes
No Apologies
Marshall Mathers
Headlights
Deja Vu
When I'm Gone
Way I Am
Rap God
Just Don't Give a Fuck
Legacy
Survival
Role Model
On Fire
Rhyme or Reason

In that GENERAL order

[Wego]

Rock Bottom
Kill You
Kids
Still Dont Give A Fuck
Bad Influence
Kim
Stan
Till I Collapse
Criminal
Guilty Conscience

[OutlawƎ]

no order
no apologies
lose yourself
the way i am
stan
sing for the moment
rock bottom
headlights
cleanin out my closet
till i collapse
still don't give a fuck

honorable mentions - criminal , going through changes , just don't give a fuck & white america