MMLP Elimination Game (Criminal Wins)

[PAINKILLƎR]

Criminal

[Trimss]

Stan and The Way I Am are the two best songs on the MMLP.

[SliK]

Stan and The Way I Am are the two best songs on the MMLP.

Absolutely

[superman11]

I would say

1 The Way I Am
2 Criminal
3 Stan

All very very close and interchangeable but that's my personal opinion.

[PAINKILLƎR]

I would say

1 The Way I Am
2 Criminal
3 Stan

All very very close and interchangeable but that's my personal opinion.

nahhh

[Just Silver]

criminal is overrated

[superman11]

I would say

1 The Way I Am
2 Criminal
3 Stan

All very very close and interchangeable but that's my personal opinion.

nahhh

yahhhh..

I go back and forth with Criminal and Stan, but thats what I think. Criminal is just so fucking classic from the beat to the hook to the Slim Shady verses, and that last verse

[PAINKILLƎR]

I would say

1 The Way I Am
2 Criminal
3 Stan

All very very close and interchangeable but that's my personal opinion.

nahhh

yahhhh..

I go back and forth with Criminal and Stan, but thats what I think. Criminal is just so fucking classic from the beat to the hook to the Slim Shady verses, and that last verse

As much as I love Criminal and as great as it is. I would have to disagree that it's interchangable with any other track. I mean Stan is on a whole other level, there is nothing else like it. Stan is the undisputed best track off MMLP. You can make a great argument for who the runner up to that song is but I think Stan is without a doubt the best.

[superman11]

Fair enough. I love all 3 of those songs and without a doubt think they are the best 3 on that album and easily all top 10 tracks from Em, top 5 for me personally.

[Notalius]

who knew, Marshall Mathers tho >>>>>>>

[Kill You]

The way I am - the most overrated song on the LP

Tell me about it, I almost wish I picked this instead of Stan but I like it slightly better than Stan.

You say anyone who doesn't like Relapse doesn't really 'get' Eminem yet you say shit like this..

I vote Criminal

Get off of my dick, please. Tired of you commenting on everything that has to do with me, if you hate me that badly then ignore me.

I can't like The Way I Am a little more than Stan, TWIA is about as "getting" Eminem as you can get. Stan is from the perception of a fan. Wow, you're smarter than this Slik.

[jinofthewind]

The Way I Am

[Trey]

Criminal

Edit: If Criminal Loses, this thread title better change to "MMLP Elimination Game (Criminal has been robbed.)"

[Kill You]

Criminal

Edit: If Criminal Loses, this thread title better change to "MMLP Elimination Game (Criminal has been robbed.)"

I second this.

[Trimss]

In no way, shape or form Criminal is the best song on the album. That's like saying Soldier is the best on TES.

It's an amazing track but not best of the album contender.