Most underrated Eminem album?

[Just Silver]

Slim shady lp

[jinofthewind]

Listenable songs on Encore - Evil Deeds. Never Enough. Yellow Brick Road. Like Toy Soldiers. Mosh. Puke. Rain Man. Spend Some Time. Mockingbird. Crazy In Love. One Shot 2 Shot. Encore. We As Americans. Love You More. Ricky Ticky Toc.

Listenable songs on Relapse - 3am. Stay Wide Awake. Must be the Ganja. Deja Vu. Beautiful. Underground. My Darling. Be Careful What You Wish For. Hell Breaks Loose. Drop the Bomb on Em. Elevator. Music Box.

Encore still wins. Come at me.

Fixed

Stopped reading at Rain Man.

edit i wasnt including refill or the encore bonus tracks... i thought that was obvious... i guess not... but glad we agree overall

You included My Darling already tho

[Snakebeast]

So much idiocy in this thread.

[Just Silver]

Elaborate

[Snakebeast]

Csw and jinofthewind.

Relapse is overrated. But Encore is fucking shit.

[Just Silver]

Encore isn't that bad but I wouldn't say it's underrated because it sorta deserves the back burner

[jinofthewind]

Csw and jinofthewind.

Relapse is overrated. But Encore is fucking shit.

Encore isn't fucking shit. Big Weenie, My 1st Single, Just Lose It and Ass Like That are shit.

Encore isn't that bad but I wouldn't say it's underrated because it sorta deserves the back burner

Yeah I can understand the criticism that it gets but I feel that it's not worth what people give it in response

[Just Silver]

Like toy soldiers is awesome

[mdemaz]

Encore.

[4Corners]

Most overrated on TR is Relapse, his most underrated on here is Recovery.

[Shady50]

I personally think Recovery is underrated. There are some really good songs on the album and many of the songs are very meaningful. Relapse is underrated by the mainstream audience that knows nothing about real hip-hop and lyricism. Even though Encore is his worst album, it still has some of his best work to date. Most people only look at the negatives of Encore, but overall it's actually a pretty solid album.

[Snakebeast]

Csw and jinofthewind.

Relapse is overrated. But Encore is fucking shit.

Encore isn't fucking shit. Big Weenie, My 1st Single, Just Lose It and Ass Like That are shit.

Encore is fucking shit. Big Weenie's second verse at least entertained me.

Evil Deeds is dogshit. Repeating the same fucking shit over and over does not constitute a verse.

Never Enough has Eminem using that lazy "Sha-dee" rhyme scheme. HORRIBLE rhyming. BUT WAIT, WE HAVE FIFTY CENT!!!.....who does nothing but bring the song down further. Not a horrible song, but not good by any means. Something that brings it up is the fantastic hook.

Yellow Brick Road had some weird rhyming, but it was a good song.

Like Toy Soldiers once again has lazy rhyming, but great song, aside from the rather annoying hook, which isn't as bad as everyone says.

Mosh is Eminem spouting bullshit about something he knows nothing about.

Puke is worse than horseshit. No explanation required.

Rain Man was hilarious. Not good, but Em wasn't trying too hard to be funny or anything. It was a stupid song, and he knew it.

Spend Some Time had probably the best Em verse on the whole album. Everything else about that song is pure shit.

Mockingbird is laughable. Em slurring words together while trying to sing. Not a bad concept, but HORRIBLY executed.

Crazy In Love.....what the fuck is this.

One Shot Two Shot is hilarious, but shit nonetheless. No redeeming qualities.

Encore is a nice club track. It's an okay song for what it is.

So we have two good songs (which aren't even all that great) out of 16. If that's not shit, I don't know what is.

[jinofthewind]

7/16 Encore tracks were amazing
3/16 Encore tracks were good
2/16 Encore tracks were average
4/16 Encore tracks were bad
And it had decent skits/intros/outros
Evil Deeds while being average was a great opener
Great concept
Encore and Curtains Down great closer
Had 2 amazing bonus tracks and 1 good bonus track

How is this shit?

Edit...

Csw and jinofthewind.

Relapse is overrated. But Encore is fucking shit.

Encore isn't fucking shit. Big Weenie, My 1st Single, Just Lose It and Ass Like That are shit.

Encore is fucking shit. Big Weenie's second verse at least entertained me.

Evil Deeds is dogshit. Repeating the same fucking shit over and over does not constitute a verse.

Never Enough has Eminem using that lazy "Sha-dee" rhyme scheme. HORRIBLE rhyming. BUT WAIT, WE HAVE FIFTY CENT!!!.....who does nothing but bring the song down further. Not a horrible song, but not good by any means. Something that brings it up is the fantastic hook.

Yellow Brick Road had some weird rhyming, but it was a good song.

Like Toy Soldiers once again has lazy rhyming, but great song, aside from the rather annoying hook, which isn't as bad as everyone says.

Mosh is Eminem spouting bullshit about something he knows nothing about.

Puke is worse than horseshit. No explanation required.

Rain Man was hilarious. Not good, but Em wasn't trying too hard to be funny or anything. It was a stupid song, and he knew it.

Spend Some Time had probably the best Em verse on the whole album. Everything else about that song is pure shit.

Mockingbird is laughable. Em slurring words together while trying to sing. Not a bad concept, but HORRIBLY executed.

Crazy In Love.....what the fuck is this.

One Shot Two Shot is hilarious, but shit nonetheless. No redeeming qualities.

Encore is a nice club track. It's an okay song for what it is.

So we have two good songs (which aren't even all that great) out of 16. If that's not shit, I don't know what is.

I agree with literally nothing you posted here

[Snakebeast]

7/16 Encore tracks were amazing

What?



Name them, and I will tell you why you are wrong.

[Just Silver]

So much encore hate damn