MMLP=MMLP2 on Metacritic

[TotalEminemFanboy]

Well, it appears that the critics think MMLP2 is equivalent to MMLP. I understand that not all reviews are in here and that metacritic may not be a very good indicator of what everyone thinks about the albums, I just find it interesting that both of them have the same critic score. Oh and also, make sure to give the album your review once it officially comes out and support Eminem!

MMLP: http://www.metacritic.com/music/the-marshall-mathers-lp/eminem?recent-sort=userscore
MMLP2 at the moment: http://www.metacritic.com/music/the-marshall-mathers-lp-2/eminem

MMLP: 78 Metascore
MMLP2: 78 Metascore so... it must be just as good as the original?

[Kill You]

Well, the quality of music is just as good and practically the same.

[Catastrophic]

People be drinking when they compare these two.

[fifflaren]

Lmao

you do realize that metacritic is going to count at least 20 more reviews ? and these reviews ain't that great so far

[EminemBase]

Well, the quality of music is just as good and practically the same.

What?!

Do you mean overall or just the production?

MMLP2 is nowhere near #1.

[Trilla]

Well, the quality of music is just as good and practically the same.

This proves you are legally brain-dead.

[trentimus]

Well, if we're being honest MMLP deserves anything higher than 95 and MMLP2 deserves nothing below 80.

[EminemBase]

Well, if we're being honest MMLP deserves anything higher than 95 and MMLP2 deserves nothing below 80.

MMLP1 definitely deserves 90 +.

It's because the thoughts are so abrasive and standoffish that it makes it pretty hard for something like that to get total acclaim, since Em is intentionally goading so many types of people...

But musically and artistically - that album is a 90+ album. Absurd that it's below 80.

MMLP2 I'd say is a 75.

[Rattle1]

mmlp 95+ ?

[4Corners]

By critics it was, only a fool would think otherwise. Eminem has ALWAYS been underrated by critics.

Critics say Nothing Was the Same is greater than Ems classics.....yeah fuck critics

[PAINKILLƎR]

mmlp 95+ ?

Yeah, best hip hop album of all time bar none.

[4Corners]

Marshall Mathers LP is one of the greatest hip hop albums ever.......ever

MMLP2 is more like Stillmatic.

[trentimus]

By critics it was, only a fool would think otherwise. Eminem has ALWAYS been underrated by critics.

Critics say Nothing Was the Same is greater than Ems classics.....yeah fuck critics

And Yeezus is "daring" and "near perfect".

[Rattle1]

mmlp 95+ ?

Yeah, best hip hop album of all time bar none.

I can name 20 albums better than The Marshall Mathers.

[trentimus]

mmlp 95+ ?

Yeah, best hip hop album of all time bar none.

I can name 20 albums better than The Marshall Mathers.

Go instead of pretending then.