I know for a fact that Dumpin' is from 1997. That's when the B-Flatt mixtape was recorded and released. It says so on the labels website. Plus, Dirty Dozen wasn't created until 1996, so if Dumpin' was from 1990 (by the way, I doubt Eminem was that good in 1990

1990 is only 1 year after Foolish Pride. And he was HORRIBLE on Foolish Pride) why would he say Dirty Dozen in the song? I should know all this stuff. I was the one who leaked the song on to the D12 World Forum a few weeks ago

I'm the reason you people even heard this song

Also, Eminem hadn't even met Eiy-Kyu, B-Flatt, Dirtty Ratt or Denaun Porter yet in 1990. Denaun Porter produced the song and Dirtty Ratt was in a duo with B-Flatt at the time called, Parts Unknown. At the same time as being in Parts Unknown, the two were also in Dirty Dozen. Parts Unknown is actually the group that released the mixtape, which is called, Payin' Dues. It's not just a B-Flatt mixtape. Dirtty Ratt produced every song except Dumpin', and featured on Off The Weed And Brew. B-Flatt is on every song. Fuzz Scoota features on P-Rock Sh-t.