TRShitty wrote:Here's the problem with piggybacking on the Recovery sound:
The Recovery sound was not good.
It was an OKAY ALRIGHT album. Nobody was looking for an instrumental version of Recovery.
Eminem doesn't have a "great ear for beats." He makes mediocre beats sound good through sheer talent. (Or at least he used to.)
You know who has a "great ear for beats"? Rick Ross. Every time he puts out an album, hundreds of rappers freestyle over the instrumentals....because they're dope as f-ck. (No, I'm not saying RIck Ross is great, I'm saying he has a great ear for beats, which is why his mediocre ass is relevant and sells more albums than more talented lyricists consistently.)
Recovery was good in spite of the production, not because of it.
Hmm, well, I definitely would call Recovery a lot better than 'okay alright'.
You mean the production alone though right? I agree with that.
When trying to gauge a feeling on it, it can leave you with that impression but I think that's from, well the production as you say... but everytime I listen to it again I'm like "wow". The songs and his performances on each song are mostly so strong, it's a really solid album...
As for him having a bad ear for beats... I'm not sure about that, The Slim Shady LP and The Marshall Mathers LP have great beats and he either picked them or co-produced them, and I think the beats on The Eminem Show are fantastic and he produced them all. I just think he has a very particular sound and only he, Bass Bros and Dre have been accustom to making music to fill that space... when he gets beats from outside producers he tends to want to add shit or tweak them himself too which results in it being over produced and clashy. He should just stick to rapping over his own beats.