Tracklisting: Lady Gaga - Born This Way

[classthe_king]

She has no singing ability, and I'm not just expressing an opinion. I'm talking musically, octaves wise, she has no singing ability whatsoever.

Don't get me wrong, to each their own, I just find her music appalling.

No singing ability?Saying this is nothing but an opinion,and yes octaves wise,she can sing,have you actually heard her sing or you just heard those singles?

It's not an opinion (although I do wholeheartedly agree with it), it's a fact. I've listened to two of her albums, and musically, whether you like it or not, she cannot even remotely sing. Of course, I'm not stating this based on the songs I've heard, but on her vocal range. You may think her voice sounds good, that's fine, good for you, but arguing with the fact that octaves wise she's about as talented as a plank of wood is nonsensical, because I'm stating facts.

In a studio setting, one can "fake" a vocal range (Britney's earlier work, where she produced vocals that sounded like she could sing). Lady Gaga has a catarrhal tone, and she clearly uses her chest to reach deep notes. Her vocal range by any standard is average. I don't care if you "disagree", because liking someones music has nothing to do with their vocal range.

Don't make crazy claims about her vocals man, if you like her that's fine. She's just an average singer at best, plain and simple.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NM51qOpwcIM

There's no faking that.

[Maybe]

It's ignorant of you to think that. I'm not going to argue or try to disprove your posts, because what I stated was fact. I didn't invent the vocal scale, and I didn't invent her average score. Musically, she just isn't that talented when it comes to singing. End of story.

I can also hold a high/low note for a very long time without breaking my voice, but I simply can't sing.

[classthe_king]

Who cares what octaves she can hit? If she sounds good when she sings then she's a good singer...

[Kez]

Who cares what octaves she can hit? If she sounds good when she sings then she's a good singer...

She's not a good musician though.

[classthe_king]

Who cares what octaves she can hit? If she sounds good when she sings then she's a good singer...

She's not a good musician though.

Says you?

[Kez]

Who cares what octaves she can hit? If she sounds good when she sings then she's a good singer...

She's not a good musician though.

Says you?

Yeah

[classthe_king]

That doesn't mean she doesn't make good music

[Kez]

Her music is boring. It's all the same shit heard a thousand times before, dressed up as though it's something new. If you enjoy that shit there is no reason for you not to enjoy any of the other pop singers, however you apparently hate most popular stuff, which surprises me if you like GaGa.

[BILI]

She has no singing ability, and I'm not just expressing an opinion. I'm talking musically, octaves wise, she has no singing ability whatsoever.

Don't get me wrong, to each their own, I just find her music appalling.

No singing ability?Saying this is nothing but an opinion,and yes octaves wise,she can sing,have you actually heard her sing or you just heard those singles?

It's not an opinion (although I do wholeheartedly agree with it), it's a fact. I've listened to two of her albums, and musically, whether you like it or not, she cannot even remotely sing. Of course, I'm not stating this based on the songs I've heard, but on her vocal range. You may think her voice sounds good, that's fine, good for you, but arguing with the fact that octaves wise she's about as talented as a plank of wood is nonsensical, because I'm stating facts.

In a studio setting, one can "fake" a vocal range (Britney's earlier work, where she produced vocals that sounded like she could sing). Lady Gaga has a catarrhal tone, and she clearly uses her chest to reach deep notes. Her vocal range by any standard is average. I don't care if you "disagree", because liking someones music has nothing to do with their vocal range.

Don't make crazy claims about her vocals man, if you like her that's fine. She's just an average singer at best, plain and simple.

The link class posted proves that she can sing.

I`m looking for an article on her where some acclaimed dude with degree in music said that she could be a great singer if she didnt sell out for the fortune and fame,he knew her before she became famous,therefore she most likely knew/knows how to sing.Also you cant go against the vid class posted,she sings there man,wtf?

I mean she`s not some opera singer,or something mindblowing,but to say that she cant sing is false,she does fake here vocals on most of her songs,that way they sound more appealing for the clubs and shit.But its not like she cant sing,its that she really doesnt want to,she sells this way,in any other normal way she would just be one out of millions who never made it.

[classthe_king]

Her music is boring. It's all the same shit heard a thousand times before, dressed up as though it's something new. If you enjoy that shit there is no reason for you not to enjoy any of the other pop singers, however you apparently hate most popular stuff, which surprises me if you like GaGa.

Gaga isn't anything like any other pop singers.

[Kez]

Her music is boring. It's all the same shit heard a thousand times before, dressed up as though it's something new. If you enjoy that shit there is no reason for you not to enjoy any of the other pop singers, however you apparently hate most popular stuff, which surprises me if you like GaGa.

Gaga isn't anything like any other pop singers.

Because...?

[classthe_king]

Her music is boring. It's all the same shit heard a thousand times before, dressed up as though it's something new. If you enjoy that shit there is no reason for you not to enjoy any of the other pop singers, however you apparently hate most popular stuff, which surprises me if you like GaGa.

Gaga isn't anything like any other pop singers.

Because...?

Because when I listen to her music I get a sense of wonderment and awe and when I listen to music from any other pop star I want to cut my ears off.

[Kez]

Because when I listen to her music I get a sense of wonderment and awe and when I listen to music from any other pop star I want to cut my ears off.

But why? She doesn't sing about anything different or more interesting than any other pop singer. Are you enticed by the videos of her shaking her ass at the screen perhaps? Or all those pretty costumes she wears?

[classthe_king]

Because when I listen to her music I get a sense of wonderment and awe and when I listen to music from any other pop star I want to cut my ears off.

But why? She doesn't sing about anything different or more interesting than any other pop singer. Are you enticed by the videos of her shaking her ass at the screen perhaps? Or all those pretty costumes she wears?

I've never watched one of those videos so know. And I don't really care about what she sings about. I listen to rap for lyrics.

[Kez]

And I don't really care about what she sings about. I listen to rap for lyrics.

Wow, so basically she could sing about getting fucked in the butt to a catchy electronica tune and you would go out and buy it? Interesting. But if you can't even justify why she is supposedly good past the fact that you personally enjoy the sound of it, then you aint convincing anyone lmao