The TRshady Forum became read-only in December 2014. The 10 year history will live on, in this archive.
Continue the discussion with the new home for the Eminem and Hip Hop discussion: HipHopShelter.com.

Album Rating song by song

Here you can review anything related to Slim Shady

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby CLV22798 » Oct 14th, '10, 06:09

classthe_king wrote:It's because I've only listened to Recovery 1.5 times all the way through and it was when it leaked so I honestly can't give you a ranking for it's songs. I don't even remember them lol. Back when I was a Stan I listend to Encore still so I remember how good each song was, but Recovery would probably be right around Relapse = or - it's score by around 5%.

And lol at some dude giving Recovery a 100%. Yeah I'm sure every song was a perfect 10/10 :laughing:



It seems like everytime I state my opinion of Recovery, somebody has something bad to say about it. Just because you didn't like Recovery, doesn't mean I'm gonna have the same opinion as you. TES used to be my favorite Eminem album, but I feel like Recovery tops it. I found it hilarious that you put Recovery up there with Relapse. But, you don't see me bashing your opinion. That's because I respect people's opinion, even if I don't agree with it.
CLV22798
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 111
Joined: Jun 8th, '10, 03:12

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby classthe_king » Oct 14th, '10, 11:54

CLV22798 wrote:
classthe_king wrote:It's because I've only listened to Recovery 1.5 times all the way through and it was when it leaked so I honestly can't give you a ranking for it's songs. I don't even remember them lol. Back when I was a Stan I listend to Encore still so I remember how good each song was, but Recovery would probably be right around Relapse = or - it's score by around 5%.

And lol at some dude giving Recovery a 100%. Yeah I'm sure every song was a perfect 10/10 :laughing:



It seems like everytime I state my opinion of Recovery, somebody has something bad to say about it. Just because you didn't like Recovery, doesn't mean I'm gonna have the same opinion as you. TES used to be my favorite Eminem album, but I feel like Recovery tops it. I found it hilarious that you put Recovery up there with Relapse. But, you don't see me bashing your opinion. That's because I respect people's opinion, even if I don't agree with it.


You gave it a 100%. Do you understand what that means :laughing:

What a fucking dipshit
You think your personal attacks make up for what you lack?
User avatar
classthe_king
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 14163
Joined: Feb 12th, '09, 02:30
Location: Ohio
Gender: Male

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby MikeNUFC » Oct 14th, '10, 16:30

classthe_king wrote:It's because I've only listened to Recovery 1.5 times all the way through

Your opinion on the album is now invalid.
MikeNUFC
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 6672
Joined: Oct 7th, '09, 19:56
Gender: Male

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby CLV22798 » Oct 14th, '10, 18:29

classthe_king wrote:
CLV22798 wrote:
classthe_king wrote:It's because I've only listened to Recovery 1.5 times all the way through and it was when it leaked so I honestly can't give you a ranking for it's songs. I don't even remember them lol. Back when I was a Stan I listend to Encore still so I remember how good each song was, but Recovery would probably be right around Relapse = or - it's score by around 5%.

And lol at some dude giving Recovery a 100%. Yeah I'm sure every song was a perfect 10/10 :laughing:



It seems like everytime I state my opinion of Recovery, somebody has something bad to say about it. Just because you didn't like Recovery, doesn't mean I'm gonna have the same opinion as you. TES used to be my favorite Eminem album, but I feel like Recovery tops it. I found it hilarious that you put Recovery up there with Relapse. But, you don't see me bashing your opinion. That's because I respect people's opinion, even if I don't agree with it.


You gave it a 100%. Do you understand what that means :laughing:

What a fucking dipshit



Of course I understand what it means, I think Recovery is his best album. I don't think there's one bad song on it, which is why I gave it a 100%. It's like if you do a test and you don't get one question wrong, you would get a 100%. That's what I did with Recovery, I liked every song on the album and I consider it a classic album. I still don't understand why you can't respect my opinion, did you see me bashing your opinion of not liking Recovery?
CLV22798
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 111
Joined: Jun 8th, '10, 03:12

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby classthe_king » Oct 14th, '10, 23:08

No you dumb fuck. That's not the percent of all the songs on the album you like, you're supossed to take the mean of every song and make that the percent of the album :laughing:
You giving it a 100% means you think every song is a perfect 10/10.
You think your personal attacks make up for what you lack?
User avatar
classthe_king
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 14163
Joined: Feb 12th, '09, 02:30
Location: Ohio
Gender: Male

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby NicoleEM » Oct 15th, '10, 00:07

CLV22798 wrote:Slim Shady LP



Recovery:


Cold Wind Blows: 10/10
Talkin 2 Myself: 10/10
On Fire: 7/10
Won't Back Down: 8/10
WTP: 8/10
Going Through Changes: 10/10
Not Afraid: 9/10
Seduction: 9/10
No Love: 9/10
Space Bound: 10/10
Cinderella Man: 10/10
25 To Life: 10/10
So Bad: 8/10
Almost Famous: 10/10
Love The Way You Lie: 10/10
You're Never Over: 10/10
Untitled: 9/10


Album Rating: 100%

I think what class is trying to explain is is that u have to make a sum of the notes u gave to each song and then make an album rating.You didnt rate all the songs on it 10/10. :whistle:
Image
"You just hurt my god damn feelin' and that was the last one i had"
User avatar
NicoleEM
Renegade
Renegade
 
Posts: 2421
Joined: Sep 30th, '10, 21:15
Gender: Female

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby NicoleEM » Oct 15th, '10, 00:16

My turn:
SSLP 85%

My Name Is 8/10
Guilty Conscience 8/10
Brain Damage 8/10
If I had 10/10
Bonnie and Clyde 9/10
Role Model 9/10
My Fault 8/10
Cum on Everybody 7/10
Rock Bottom: 10/10
Just Don't Give a fuck: 9/10
As the world Turns 9/10
I'm Shady 7/10
Bad Meets Evil 9/10
Still Don't Give a Fuck 8/10
Get You Mad(not on SSLP)

MMLP 89%

Kill You 10/10
Stan 9/10
Who Knew 8/10
The Way I am 10/10
The Real Slim Shady 9/10
Remember Me 8/10
I'm Back 8/10
Marshall Mathers 10/10
Drug Ballad 9/10
Amityville 7/10
Bitch Please II 9/10
Kim 9/10
Under the Influence 9/10
Criminal 10/10
The Kids(not on MMLP)

TES 90%

Business 9/10
Cleanin Out My Closet 9/10
Drips 8/10
Hailie's Song 8/10
My Dad's Gone Crazy 9/10
Say Goodbye to Hollywood 10/10
Say What You Say 9/10
Sing for the Moment 10/10
Soldier 9/10
Square Dance 9/10
Superman 8/10
Till I Collapse 10/10
When the Music Stops 9/10
White America 9/10
Without Me 9/10

Encore 75%

Evil Deeds 9/10
Never Enough 7/10
Yellow Brick Road 7/10
Like Toy Soldiers 9/10
Mosh 8/10
Puke 7/10
My 1st Single 6/10
Rain Man 6/10
Big Weenie 6/10
Just Lose It 5/10
Ass Like That 6/10
Spend Some Time 9/10
Mockingbird 8/10
Crazy In Love 9/10
One shot 2 Shot 8/10
Encore 8/10
We As Americans 7/10
Love You More 10/10
Ricky Ticky Toc 8/10

Relapse 81%

3AM 7/10
My Mom 7/10
Insane 8/10
Bagpipes from Baghdad 8/10
Hello 8/10
Same Song and Dance 9/10
We Made You 7/10
Medicine Ball 7/10
Stay Wide Awake 8/10
Old Time's Sake 7/10
Must be the Ganja 8/10
Deja Vu 10/10
Beautiful 9/10
Crack a Bottle 7/10
Underground 10/10
Careful What You Wish For 9/10
My Darling 9/10

Refill 77%

Forever 9/10(rated Em's part)
Hell breaks loose 7/10
Buffalo Bill 6/10
Elevator 7/10
Taking my ball 8/10
Music box 8/10
Drop the bomb on em 7/10
Psycho 9/10

Recovery 84%

Cold Wind Blows: 9/10
Talkin 2 Myself: 8/10
On Fire: 8/10
Won't Back Down: 7/10
W.T.P: 8/10
Going Through Changes: 9/10
Not Afraid: 8/10
Seduction10/10(Someone forgot it :'( )
No Love: 9/10
Space Bound: 10/10
Cinderella Man: 8/10
25 To Life: 9/10
So Bad: 8/10
Almost Famous: 9/10
Love the way you Lie: 8/10
You're never Over: 9/10
Untitled: 8/10
Ridaz: 8/10
Session One: 8/10
Image
"You just hurt my god damn feelin' and that was the last one i had"
User avatar
NicoleEM
Renegade
Renegade
 
Posts: 2421
Joined: Sep 30th, '10, 21:15
Gender: Female

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby CLV22798 » Oct 15th, '10, 03:29

classthe_king wrote:No you dumb fuck. That's not the percent of all the songs on the album you like, you're supossed to take the mean of every song and make that the percent of the album :laughing:
You giving it a 100% means you think every song is a perfect 10/10.



Just because you rate tracks like that doesn't mean that I do it the same way. I already told you the way I rated the album since I liked doing it that way, but whatever at least I'm not the dumb fuck who would put Recovery up there with Relapse. When truthfully, Relapse is actually right up there with Encore.
CLV22798
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 111
Joined: Jun 8th, '10, 03:12

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby classthe_king » Oct 15th, '10, 03:41

CLV22798 wrote:
classthe_king wrote:No you dumb fuck. That's not the percent of all the songs on the album you like, you're supossed to take the mean of every song and make that the percent of the album :laughing:
You giving it a 100% means you think every song is a perfect 10/10.



Just because you rate tracks like that doesn't mean that I do it the same way. I already told you the way I rated the album since I liked doing it that way, but whatever at least I'm not the dumb fuck who would put Recovery up there with Relapse. When truthfully, Relapse is actually right up there with Encore.


You calling me dumb is laughable after you just looked like a retard earlier in this thread. Just stop posting here, it's making you look worse and worse each time.
You think your personal attacks make up for what you lack?
User avatar
classthe_king
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 14163
Joined: Feb 12th, '09, 02:30
Location: Ohio
Gender: Male

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby CLV22798 » Oct 15th, '10, 03:51

classthe_king wrote:
CLV22798 wrote:
classthe_king wrote:No you dumb fuck. That's not the percent of all the songs on the album you like, you're supossed to take the mean of every song and make that the percent of the album :laughing:
You giving it a 100% means you think every song is a perfect 10/10.



Just because you rate tracks like that doesn't mean that I do it the same way. I already told you the way I rated the album since I liked doing it that way, but whatever at least I'm not the dumb fuck who would put Recovery up there with Relapse. When truthfully, Relapse is actually right up there with Encore.


You calling me dumb is laughable after you just looked like a retard earlier in this thread. Just stop posting here, it's making you look worse and worse each time.



Ha, to me you're the one that looked bad the moment you posted in this thread. So, you are the last person I care about that judges me in this thread.
CLV22798
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 111
Joined: Jun 8th, '10, 03:12

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby classthe_king » Oct 15th, '10, 03:58

Ok CLV22798 :laughing:

You have a lot to learn buddy :coffee:
You think your personal attacks make up for what you lack?
User avatar
classthe_king
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 14163
Joined: Feb 12th, '09, 02:30
Location: Ohio
Gender: Male

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby Banks » Oct 15th, '10, 04:33

I dont know how I do the final sum, which rule to follow ... :(
User avatar
Banks
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1490
Joined: Nov 23rd, '09, 17:26
Gender: Male

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby OneFallsRich » Oct 17th, '10, 21:03

SSLP:

My Name Is: 9/10
Guilty Conscience: 6/10
Brain Damage: 8/10
If I had: 8/10
Bonnie And Clyde: 6/10
Role Model: 10/10
My Fault: 6/10
Cum On Everybody: 9/10
Rock Bottom: 7/10
Just Don't Give A fuck: 8/10
As The World Turns: 8/10
I'm Shady: 8/10
Bad Meets Evil: 6/10
Still Don't Give A Fuck: 8/10
Get You Mad: 8/10

Album Rating: 77%

MMLP:

Kill You: 8/10
Stan: 10/10
Who Knew: 8/10
The Way I am: 9/10
The Real Slim Shady: 10/10
Remember Me: 7/10
I'm Back: 9/10
Marshall Mathers: 9/10
Drug Ballad: 10/10
Amityville: 9/10
Bitch Please II: 9/10
Kim: 6/10
Under The Influence: 8/10
Criminal: 10/10
The Kids: 7/10

Album Rating: 86%

TES:

White America: 10/10
Business: 9/10
Cleanin Out My Closet: 10/10
Square Dance: 10/10
Soldier: 10/10
Say Goodbye To Hollywood: 10/10
Drips: 8/10
Without Me: 10/10
Sing For The Moment: 10/10
Superman: 10/10
Hailie's Song: 9/10
When The Music Stops: 9/10
Say What You Say: 6/10
Till I Collapse: 10/10
My Dad's Gone Crazy: 7/10

Album Rating: 92%

Encore:

Evil Deeds: 9/10
Never Enough: 8/10
Yellow Brick Road: 9/10
Like Toy Soldiers: 9/10
Mosh: 7/10
Puke: 4/10
My 1st Single: 4/10
Rain Man: 5/10
Big Weenie: 5/10
Just Lose It: 7/10
Ass Like That: 7/10
Spend Some Time: 8/10
Mockingbird: 8/10
Crazy In Love: 6/10
One Shot 2 Shot: 7/10
Encore: 9/10
We As Americans: 8/10
Love You More: 10/10
Ricky Ticky Toc: 6/10

Album Rating: 72%

Relapse Refill:

3AM: 7/10
My Mom: 8/10
Insane: 8/10
Bagpipes From Baghdad: 9/10
Hello: 8/10
Same Song And Dance: 7/10
We Made You: 6/10
Medicine Ball: 7/10
Stay Wide Awake: 9/10
Old Time's Sake: 7/10
Must Be The Ganja: 6/10
Deja Vu: 8/10
Beautiful: 10/10
Crack A Bottle: 7/10
Underground: 9/10
Careful What You Wish For: 8/10
My Darling: 6/10
Forever 8/10
Hell Breaks Loose 8/10
Buffalo Bill 7/10
Elevator 8/10
Taking My Ball 7/10
Music Box 7/10
Drop The Bomb On Em 6/10

Album Rating: 75%

Recovery:

Cold Wind Blows: 9/10
Talkin' 2 Myself: 10/10
On Fire: 7/10
Won't Back Down: 6/10
W.T.P.: 8/10
Going Through Changes: 7/10
Not Afraid: 9/10
Seduction: 8/10
No Love: 10/10
Space Bound: 10/10
Cinderella Man: 10/10
25 To Life: 10/10
So Bad: 10/10
Almost Famous: 8/10
Love The Way You Lie: 9/10
You're Never Over: 8/10
Untitled: 8/10
Ridaz: 6/10
Session One: 7/10

Album Rating: 84%

So Em has averaged a 81%.
I'm only entertaining you
My goal is to stimulate, making you high
And take you and I
To a place you can't see
But I believe you can fly
I don't mean nobody harm, I'm just partying
I'm not your dad, not your mom, not your guardian
Just a man who's on the mic
So let me entertain you...
User avatar
OneFallsRich
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 673
Joined: Jan 18th, '10, 19:52
Location: Germany
Gender: Male

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby Oby One » Oct 27th, '10, 18:23

SSLP

My Name Is: 8/10
Guilty Conscience: 8/10
Brain Damage: 9/10
If I had: 9/10
Bonnie and Clyde: 9/10
Role Model: 10/10
My Fault: 8/10
Cum on Everybody: 8/10
Rock Bottom: 10/10
Just Don't Give a fuck: 10/10
As the world Turns: 9/10
I'm Shady: 9/10
Bad Meets Evil: 9/10
Still Don't Give a Fuck: 10/10
Get You Mad: 9/10

Album Rating : 90.6%

MMLP

Kill You: 10/10
Stan: 10/10
Who Knew: 10/10
The Way I am: 10/10
The Real Slim Shady: 9/10
Remember Me: 9/10
I'm Back: 10/10
Marshall Mathers: 10/10
Drug Ballad: 9/10
Amityville: 8/10
Bitch Please II: 9/10
Kim: 10/10
Under the Influence: 8/10
Criminal: 10/10
The Kids: 9/10

Album Rating: 94%

TES

White America: 9/10
Business: 9/10
Cleanin Out My Closet: 10/10
Square Dance: 10/10
Soldier: 10/10
Say Goodbye to Hollywood: 9/10
Drips: 8/10
Without Me: 9/10
Sing for the Moment: 10/10
Superman: 9/10
Hailie's Song: 10/10
When the Music Stops: 10/10
Say What You Say: 9/10
Till I Collapse: 10/10
My Dad's Gone Crazy: 10/10

Album Rating: 94.6%

Encore

Evil Deeds: 7/10
Never Enough: 7/10
Yellow Brick Road: 9/10
Like Toy Soldiers: 8/10
Mosh: 8/10
Puke: 6/10
My 1st Single: 1/10
Rain Man: 1/10
Big Weenie: 1/10
Just Lose It: 6/10
Ass Like That: 3/10
Spend Some Time: 9/10
Mockingbird: 10/10
Crazy In Love: 7/10
One shot 2 Shot: 7/10
Encore: 7/10
We As Americans: 9/10
Love You More: 10/10
Ricky Ticky Toc: 8/10

Album Rating: 68%

Relapse

3AM: 10/10
My Mom: 7/10
Insane: 8/10
Bagpipes from Baghdad: 8/10
Hello: 10/10
Same Song and Dance: 8/10
We Made You: 4/10
Medicine Ball: 7/10
Stay Wide Awake: 8/10
Old Time's Sake: 8/10
Must be the Ganja: 9/10
Deja Vu: 10/10
Beautiful: 9/10
Crack a Bottle: 7/10
Underground: 10/10
Careful What You Wish For: 8/10
My Darling: 8/10

Album Rating: 81.7%

Recovery


Cold Wind Blows: 9/10
Talkin 2 Myself: 9/10
On Fire: 9/10
Won't Back Down: 6/10
W.T.P: 8/10
Going Through Changes: 9/10
Not Afraid: 7/10
No Love: 9/10
Space Bound: 9/10
Cinderella Man: 9/10
25 To Life: 9/10
So Bad: 9/10
Almost Famous: 10/10
Love the way you Lie: 7/10
You're never Over: 10/10
Untitled: 9/10
Ridaz: 7/10
Session One: 8/10

Album Rating: 85%
Disaprin... come from within.
User avatar
Oby One
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 346
Joined: Sep 4th, '10, 16:50
Location: Bucharest, Romania

Re: Album Rating song by song

Postby KillahBee » Oct 27th, '10, 18:50

SSLP

My Name Is: 7.5/10
Guilty Conscience: 9/10
Brain Damage: 10/10
If I had: 9/10
Bonnie and Clyde: 9/10
Role Model: 10/10
My Fault: 8/10
Cum on Everybody: 8/10
Rock Bottom: 10/10
Just Don't Give a fuck: 9/10
As the world Turns: 9.5/10
I'm Shady: 8.5/10
Bad Meets Evil: 9/10
Still Don't Give a Fuck: 10/10

MMLP:

Kill You: 10/10
Stan: 10/10
Who Knew: 9.5/10
The Way I am: 10/10
The Real Slim Shady: 8/10
Remember Me: 9/10
I'm Back: 9/10
Marshall Mathers: 10/10
Drug Ballad: 8/10
Amityville: 8.5/10
Bitch Please II: 9/10
Kim: 9/10
Under the Influence: 7.5/10
Criminal: 10/10

TES

White America: 9/10
Business: 8/10
Cleanin Out My Closet: 9/10
Square Dance: 8/10
Soldier: 9/10
Say Goodbye to Hollywood: 9/10
Drips: 5/10
Without Me: 8/10
Sing for the Moment: 10/10
Superman: 8/10
Hailie's Song: 8.5/10
When the Music Stops: 8/10
Say What You Say: 8/10
Till I Collapse: 10/10
My Dad's Gone Crazy: 8.5/10


Encore

Evil Deeds: 5/10
Never Enough: 6/10
Yellow Brick Road: 8/10
Like Toy Soldiers: 8/10
Mosh: 8/10
Puke: 5/10
My 1st Single: 1/10
Rain Man: 7/10
Big Weenie: 3/10
Just Lose It: 3/10
Ass Like That: 2/10
Spend Some Time: 7.5/10
Mockingbird: 7/10
Crazy In Love: 7/10
One shot 2 Shot: 6/10
Encore: 7/10


Relapse

3AM: 8/10
My Mom: 7.5/10
Insane: 7.5/10
Bagpipes from Baghdad: 8/10
Hello: 7.5/10
Same Song and Dance: 8/10
We Made You: 5/10
Medicine Ball: 8/10
Stay Wide Awake: 9/10
Old Time's Sake: 5/10
Must be the Ganja: 7.5/10
Deja Vu: 9.5/10
Beautiful: 9/10
Crack a Bottle: 5/10
Underground: 8.5/10


Recovery

Cold Wind Blows: 8/10
Talkin 2 Myself: 8.5/10
On Fire: 8/10
Won't Back Down: 6/10
W.T.P: 7/10
Going Through Changes: 9.5/10
Not Afraid: 6/10
Seduction: 8.5/10
No Love: 8.5/10
Space Bound: 9/10
Cinderella Man: 8/10
25 To Life: 9/10
So Bad: 7/10
Almost Famous: 9/10
Love the way you Lie: 8/10
You're never Over: 7/10
Untitled: 8/10
Same sword they knight you they gon' good night you with
Sh.., Thats' only half if they like you
That ain't even the half what they might do
Don't believe me, ask Michael
See Martin, see Malcolm
You see Biggie, see Pac, see success and its outcome
See Jesus, see Judas; see Caesar, see Brutus
See success is like suicide
Suicide, it's a suicide
If you succeed, prepare to be crucified
[/i
- Jay-Z


I'm on my balcony, seeing through the eyes of Tony
User avatar
KillahBee
Renegade
Renegade
 
Posts: 2012
Joined: Aug 2nd, '09, 20:40
Location: Slum Village
Gender: Male

PreviousNext

Return to Shady Reviews



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users