Album Rating song by song

[Bistnal]

Seen a similar thread, but not going song by song.

SSLP

My Name Is: 7/10
Guilty Conscience: 9/10
Brain Damage: 9/10
If I had: 8/10
Bonnie and Clyde: 9/10
Role Model: 9/10
My Fault: 7/10
Cum on Everybody: 7/10
Rock Bottom: 10/10
Just Don't Give a fuck: 9/10
As the world Turns: 9/10
I'm Shady: 8/10
Bad Meets Evil: 9/10
Still Don't Give a Fuck: 10/10
Get You Mad: 9/10

Album Rating: 80%

MMLP:

Kill You: 10/10
Stan: 9/10
Who Knew: 9/10
The Way I am: 10/10
The Real Slim Shady: 8/10
Remember Me: 8/10
I'm Back: 10/10
Marshall Mathers: 10/10
Drug Ballad: 8/10
Amityville: 8/10
Bitch Please II: 9/10
Kim: 9/10
Under the Influence: 9/10
Criminal: 10/10
The Kids: 7/10

Album Rating: 89%

TES

White America: 9/10
Business: 8/10
Cleanin Out My Closet: 10/10
Square Dance: 10/10
Soldier: 9/10
Say Goodbye to Hollywood: 10/10
Drips: 7/10
Without Me: 8/10
Sing for the Moment: 10/10
Superman: 8/10
Hailie's Song: 9/10
When the Music Stops: 9/10
Say What You Say: 8/10
Till I Collapse: 10/10
My Dad's Gone Crazy: 10/10

Album Rating: 90%

Encore

Evil Deeds: 5/10
Never Enough: 6/10
Yellow Brick Road: 8/10
Like Toy Soldiers: 8/10
Mosh: 8/10
Puke: 5/10
My 1st Single: 1/10
Rain Man: 3/10
Big Weenie: 3/10
Just Lose It: 5/10
Ass Like That: 4/10
Spend Some Time: 8/10
Mockingbird: 9/10
Crazy In Love: 9/10
One shot 2 Shot: 6/10
Encore: 7/10
We As Americans: 9/10
Love You More: 9/10
Ricky Ticky Toc: 8/10

Album Rating: 64%

Relapse

3AM: 8/10
My Mom: 7/10
Insane: 7/10
Bagpipes from Baghdad: 6/10
Hello: 6/10
Same Song and Dance: 7/10
We Made You: 4/10
Medicine Ball: 6/10
Stay Wide Awake: 10/10
Old Time's Sake: 5/10
Must be the Ganja: 7/10
Deja Vu: 10/10
Beautiful: 7/10
Crack a Bottle: 6/10
Underground: 9/10
Careful What You Wish For: 7/10
My Darling: 8/10

Album Rating: 71%

Recovery

Cold Wind Blows: 8/10
Talkin 2 Myself: 8/10
On Fire: 8/10
Won't Back Down: 6/10
W.T.P: 7/10
Going Through Changes: 9/10
Not Afraid: 6/10
No Love: 7/10
Space Bound: 9/10
Cinderella Man: 9/10
25 To Life: 9/10
So Bad: 7/10
Almost Famous: 9/10
Love the way you Lie: 8/10
You're never Over: 8/10
Untitled: 8/10
Ridaz: 6/10
Session One: 8/10

Album Rating: 77%

So Em has averaged a 79%.

That was interesting. Took longer than I thought it would.

[classthe_king]

I'll do them probably tonight if I'm bored but I did Encore and it got like 43% lol

[Bistnal]

I'll do them probably tonight if I'm bored but I did Encore and it got like 43% lol

lol and I thought my score of 64 was low (but accurate)

[classthe_king]

My Name Is: 6/10
Guilty Conscience: 8/10
Brain Damage: 9/10
If I had: 7/10
Bonnie and Clyde: 7/10
Role Model: 9/10
My Fault: 8/10
Cum on Everybody: 7/10
Rock Bottom: 10/10
Just Don't Give a fuck: 9/10
As the world Turns: 9/10
I'm Shady: 7/10
Bad Meets Evil: 8/10
Still Don't Give a Fuck: 9/10

8.07/10

Kill You: 8/10
Stan: 9/10
Who Knew: 9/10
The Way I am: 8/10
The Real Slim Shady: 7/10
Remember Me: 7/10
I'm Back: 9/10
Marshall Mathers: 8/10
Drug Ballad:8/10
Amityville: 7/10
Bitch Please II: 8/10
Kim: 6/10
Under the Influence: 7/10
Criminal: 9/10

7.86/10

White America: 8/10
Business: 7/10
Cleanin Out My Closet: 8/10
Square Dance: 8/10
Soldier: 9/10
Say Goodbye to Hollywood: 9/10
Drips: 7/10
Without Me: 7/10
Sing for the Moment: 10/10
Superman: 7/10
Hailie's Song: 8/10
When the Music Stops: 7/10
Say What You Say: 7/10
Till I Collapse: 9/10
My Dad's Gone Crazy: 8/10

7.93/10


Evil Deeds: 6/10
Never Enough: 6/10
Yellow Brick Road: 7/10
Like Toy Soldiers: 9/10
Mosh: 6/10
Puke: 2/10
My First Single: 1/10
Rainman: 2/10
Big Weenie: 0/10
Just Lose It: 2/10
Ass Like That: 2/10
Spend Some Time: 8/10
Mockingbird: 8/10
Crazy In Love: 3/10
One Shot 2 Shot: 2/10
Encore: 7/10

4.43/10

3AM: 7/10
My Mom: 6/10
Insane: 5/10
Bagpipes from Baghdad: 6/10
Hello: 7/10
Same Song and Dance:7/10
We Made You: 4/10
Medicine Ball: 6/10
Stay Wide Awake: 8/10
Old Time's Sake: 6/10
Must be the Ganja: 6/10
Deja Vu: 7/10
Beautiful: 8/10
Crack a Bottle: 3/10
Underground: 7/10

6.2/10

[MakaveliTheDon]

^ Damn those are low scores.

[classthe_king]

^ Damn those are low scores.

Not really, it's just all about standards. I'd probably give 6-10 songs all time a 10/10. So a 9/10 is still an amazing song, an 8/10 is great, 7/10 is really good, 6/10 is good and 5 below would be not as good.

[MakaveliTheDon]

^ Damn those are low scores.

Not really, it's just all about standards. I'd probably give 6-10 songs all time a 10/10. So a 9/10 is still an amazing song, an 8/10 is great, 7/10 is really good, 6/10 is good and 5 below would be not as good.

Oh...

But, I was saying that it's surprising how low the album scores turned out.

[classthe_king]

^ Damn those are low scores.

Not really, it's just all about standards. I'd probably give 6-10 songs all time a 10/10. So a 9/10 is still an amazing song, an 8/10 is great, 7/10 is really good, 6/10 is good and 5 below would be not as good.

Oh...

But, I was saying that it's surprising how low the album scores turned out.

I know... but like I was saying it's all about standards. The way I grade songs it's impossible to get anything in the 90's so anything in the 80's is a 5 Star album and TES and MMLP came pretty close so they would both probably get 5 Stars. Encore and Relapse just suck lol

[MakaveliTheDon]

Oh ok I get it.

Might as well start doing mine then...

[CLV22798]

Slim Shady LP


My Name Is: 8/10
Guilty Conscience: 10/10
Brain Damage: 10/10
If I Had: 5/10
Bonnie and Clyde: 7/10
Role Model: 9/10
My Fault: 9/10
Cum On Everybody: 6/10
Rock Bottom: 10/10
Just Don't Give A Fuck: 10/10
As The World Turns: 9/10
I'm Shady: 8/10
Bad Meets Evil: 9/10
Still Don't Give a Fuck: 10/10


Album Rating: 90%


Marshall Mathers LP:


Kill You: 10/10
Stan: 10/10
Who Knew: 10/10
The Way I Am: 10/10
The Real Slim Shady: 9/10
Remember Me: 6/10
I'm Back: 8/10
Marshall Mathers: 9/10
Drug Ballad: 7/10
Amityville: 7/10
Bitch Please II: 9/10
Kim: 6/10
Under The Influence: 6/10
Criminal: 10/10


Album Rating: 90%


The Eminem Show:


White America: 10/10
Business: 8/10
Cleanin Out My Closet: 9/10
Square Dance: 9/10
Soldier: 10/10
Say Goodbye To Hollywood: 10/10
Drips: 5/10
Without Me: 8/10
Sing For The Moment: 10/10
Superman: 9/10
Hailie's Song: 9/10
When The Music Stops: 8/10
Say What You Say: 7/10
Till I Collapse: 10/10
My Dad's Gone Crazy: 9/10


Album Rating: 95%


Encore:


Evil Deeds: 7/10
Never Enough: 7/10
Yellow Brick Road: 5/10
Like Toy Soldiers: 10/10
Mosh: 10/10
Puke: 5/10
My 1st Single: 1/10
Rain Man: 3/10
Big Weenie: 3/10
Just Lose It: 5/10
Ass Like That: 4/10
Spend Some Time: 7/10
Mockingbird: 9/10
Crazy In Love: 8/10
One Shot 2 Shot: 7/10
Encore: 7/10


Album Rating: 65%


Relapse:


3 AM: 10/10
My Mom: 6/10
Insane: 8/10
Bagpipes from Baghdad: 8/10
Hello: 6/10
Same Song and Dance: 6/10
We Made You: 7/10
Medicine Ball: 6/10
Stay Wide Awake: 10/10
Old Time's Sake: 7/10
Must Be The Ganja: 8/10
Deja Vu: 8/10
Beautiful: 10/10
Crack a Bottle: 5/10
Underground: 10/10


Album Rating: 79%


Recovery:


Cold Wind Blows: 10/10
Talkin 2 Myself: 10/10
On Fire: 7/10
Won't Back Down: 8/10
WTP: 8/10
Going Through Changes: 10/10
Not Afraid: 9/10
Seduction: 9/10
No Love: 9/10
Space Bound: 10/10
Cinderella Man: 10/10
25 To Life: 10/10
So Bad: 8/10
Almost Famous: 10/10
Love The Way You Lie: 10/10
You're Never Over: 10/10
Untitled: 9/10


Album Rating: 100%

[nathan123]

SSLP

My Name Is: 7/10
Guilty Conscience: 9/10
Brain Damage: 9/10
If I had: 9/10
Bonnie and Clyde: 9/10
Role Model: 10/10
My Fault: 8/10
Cum on Everybody: 7/10
Rock Bottom: 10/10
Just Don't Give a fuck: 9/10
As the world Turns: 9/10
I'm Shady: 8/10
Bad Meets Evil: 8/10
Still Don't Give a Fuck: 10/10
Get You Mad: 9/10

Album Rating: 88%

MMLP:

Kill You: 9/10
Stan: 10/10
Who Knew: 9/10
The Way I am: 10/10
The Real Slim Shady: 9/10
Remember Me: 7/10
I'm Back: 9/10
Marshall Mathers: 10/10
Drug Ballad: 8/10
Amityville: 7/10
Bitch Please II: 9/10
Kim: 9/10
Under the Influence: 9/10
Criminal: 10/10
The Kids: 7/10

Album Rating: 88%

TES

White America: 10/10
Business: 8/10
Cleanin Out My Closet: 10/10
Square Dance: 9/10
Soldier: 10/10
Say Goodbye to Hollywood: 9/10
Drips: 7/10
Without Me: 8/10
Sing for the Moment: 10/10
Superman: 9/10
Hailie's Song: 8/10
When the Music Stops: 8/10
Say What You Say: 8/10
Till I Collapse: 10/10
My Dad's Gone Crazy: 10/10

Album Rating: 91%

Encore

Evil Deeds: 5/10
Never Enough: 8/10
Yellow Brick Road: 6/10
Like Toy Soldiers: 8/10
Mosh: 8/10
Puke: 7/10
My 1st Single: 3/10
Rain Man: 2/10
Big Weenie: 5/10
Just Lose It: 5/10
Ass Like That: 6/10
Spend Some Time: 9/10
Mockingbird: 10/10
Crazy In Love: 9/10
One shot 2 Shot: 6/10
Encore: 8/10
We As Americans: 9/10
Love You More: 10/10
Ricky Ticky Toc: 7/10

Album Rating: 69%

Relapse

3AM: 8/10
My Mom: 7/10
Insane: 6/10
Bagpipes from Baghdad: 6/10
Hello: 7/10
Same Song and Dance: 8/10
We Made You: 5/10
Medicine Ball: 5/10
Stay Wide Awake: 10/10
Old Time's Sake: 7/10
Must be the Ganja: 7/10
Deja Vu: 10/10
Beautiful: 9/10
Crack a Bottle: 6/10
Underground: 9/10
Careful What You Wish For: 8/10
My Darling: 7/10

Album Rating: 74%

Recovery

Cold Wind Blows: 8/10
Talkin 2 Myself: 9/10
On Fire: 7/10
Won't Back Down: 7/10
W.T.P: 8/10
Going Through Changes: 9/10
Not Afraid: 8/10
No Love: 9/10
Space Bound: 10/10
Cinderella Man: 9/10
25 To Life: 9/10
So Bad: 7/10
Almost Famous: 10/10
Love the way you Lie: 8/10
You're never Over: 9/10
Untitled: 7/10
Ridaz: 8/10
Session One: 7/10

Album Rating: 83%

Fun

[Bistnal]

^I don't have TES as top (technically) . Only 1% diff. b/t TES & MMLP. And like I've said a lot they alternate spots often.

and I think class forgot recovery because he seems to despise it lol

[Bistnal]

^I don't have TES as top (technically) . Only 1% diff. b/t TES & MMLP. And like I've said a lot they alternate spots often.

and I think class forgot recovery because he seems to despise it lol

LMAO even more than encore ?

I'm not sure about that lol. Ask him!

[classthe_king]

It's because I've only listened to Recovery 1.5 times all the way through and it was when it leaked so I honestly can't give you a ranking for it's songs. I don't even remember them lol. Back when I was a Stan I listend to Encore still so I remember how good each song was, but Recovery would probably be right around Relapse = or - it's score by around 5%.

And lol at some dude giving Recovery a 100%. Yeah I'm sure every song was a perfect 10/10

[MakaveliTheDon]

It's because I've only listened to Recovery 1.5 times all the way through and it was when it leaked so I honestly can't give you a ranking for it's songs. I don't even remember them lol. Back when I was a Stan I listend to Encore still so I remember how good each song was, but Recovery would probably be right around Relapse = or - it's score by around 5%.

And lol at some dude giving Recovery a 100%. Yeah I'm sure every song was a perfect 10/10

I thought you said Eminem got better after Relapse?