EminemFtwAllDay wrote:Blu wrote:EminemFtwAllDay wrote:Completely false. Learn rap. Kthx.
Bring points into your argument. Saying stupid shit like this is going to give you a bad reputation here.
Just saying. Kthx.
EminemInsider wrote:There's no point in shouting.
Amadeo wrote:I'm going to actually agree with you here. If your judgement is poor enough to actually choose to rap over this beat, you might have to shout.
This sounds like a hard rock instrumental, not a rap instrumental. He shouldn't have even rapped over it in the first place.
He's basically saying that there's no point in shouting on a track, but only uses that argument for a track he didn't personally like. Notice his excuse for the shouting on "Kim"? It's organic? Wait, this is a track that he likes. Let me think of an irrelevant adjective to use for that song to cover my tracks!
If you don't think there is any meaning to Wont Back down, you are a fucking idiot. Nuff' said.
No, I'm saying shouting on an emotionally-driven concept track is completely different from shouting on a punchline track.
Kim has a single pervading concept, Won't Back Down is a bunch of random bars/punchlines.
Shouting on Kim was the only logical artistic choice. Saying, "bleed, bitch, bleeeeeeeeeed" in a calm voice wouldn't make any sense whatsoever.
And not surprisingly, the shouting on Kim was natural. It came from what Eminem was really feeling at the time, and you could tell by how believable it was. It was an outstanding vocal performance.
Not so with "Won't Back Down," where the yelling is monotonous and doesn't come from a place of emotion.
But you apparently think all yelling is the same thing, which is as stupid as saying all singing is the same thing. "Duhhhh...why are people complaining about Eminem's singing on 'One Shot 2 Shot?" Stevie Wonder sings on his entire album. U like singing when Stevie Wonder doez it, but not eminemz? hypocrisyz"
