Is it arguable that Kanye West has a better disco than Em ?

[SG.]

[Raul]

In my opinion, Em has 4 classics (SSLP, MMLP, TES and Relapse)
Kanye has College Dropout, Graduation, 808 and MBDTF. Yeezus and Late Registration are better than Encore and Recovery, so...

Yes.

But MMLP>TES>College Dropout, so it's hard for me to cement my own opinion in myself.

But graduation and 808 aren't classics doe

For me Graduation is actually arguable, but 808

[Trimss]

See, I would say that Kanye has 3 great albums (Graduation, LR, 808) 1 average/bad album (Yeezus) and 2 real classics which are College Drop Out and MBDTF.


Even though Graduation will always be my favorite. But yeah, Kanye West has a better discography. That doesn't make him a better rapper though. And with Yeezus, Kanye's downfall as an artist is impressive. It seems like dude cannot make a good song anymore. Either the song has a good beat, either it has good Kanye West on it.

Rare to link the two anymore.

[King Lance]

See, I would say that Kanye has 3 great albums (Graduation, LR, 808) 1 average/bad album (Yeezus) and 2 real classics which are College Drop Out and MBDTF.


Even though Graduation will always be my favorite. But yeah, Kanye West has a better discography. That doesn't make him a better rapper though. And with Yeezus, Kanye's downfall as an artist is impressive. It seems like dude cannot make a good song anymore. Either the song has a good beat, either it has good Kanye West on it.

Rare to link the two anymore.

Em 3 classics, 2 great and 1 average album ( if not counting infinite )

he has 3 classics, 1 great and 2 average albums imo (Recovery / Encore)

[Trimss]

To the public eye, Eminem has 3 classics, 1 good album (Recovery) and two shit (Relapse/Encore)
To the fans, he has 3 classic, 1 great album, 1 average (recovery), 1 bad (encore)
To Hip Hop Heads, Eminem is white and shit

We won't ever really "nail it"

[Mr.DGAF]

To the public eye, Eminem has 3 classics, 1 good album (Recovery) and two shit (Relapse/Encore)
To the fans, he has 3 classic, 1 great album, 1 average (recovery), 1 bad (encore)
To Hip Hop Heads, Eminem is white and shit

We won't ever really "nail it"

This is basically what I'd say. I'm a fan, and love Relapse and Recovery, but I wouldn't consider Relapse great. I'd rank Relapse and Recovery as both good to average albums.

[PAINKILLƎR]

I said it first, basedbitingpainsthoughts.

[King Lance]

To the public eye, Eminem has 3 classics, 1 good album (Recovery) and two shit (Relapse/Encore)
To the fans, he has 3 classic, 1 great album, 1 average (recovery), 1 bad (encore)
To Hip Hop Heads, Eminem is white and shit

We won't ever really "nail it"

To the fans kanye has 5 classics 1 average(yeezus)

to the public eye he has 1 maybe 2 ( mbdtf & college drop out ) 3 okay and one shit album

2 far.

I'd say that Kanye has 2 classics and 2 great albums to the public eye.

[PAINKILLƎR]

Late registration is kanyes best album.

[Trimss]

Kanye has a more consistent discography than Eminem and it's undeniable. However, Em's best albums > Kanye's best albums

SSLP, MMLP, TES > Kanye's peak

BUT Kanye's lows > Eminem's lows

[King Lance]

Late registration is kanyes best album.

how is that possible when MBDTF is the rap Thriller

[ladelsofgravy]

Kanye has a more consistent discography than Eminem and it's undeniable. However, Em's best albums > Kanye's best albums

SSLP, MMLP, TES > Kanye's peak

BUT Kanye's lows > Eminem's lows

exactly

[ladelsofgravy]

Kanye has a more consistent discography than Eminem and it's undeniable. However, Em's best albums > Kanye's best albums

SSLP, MMLP, TES > Kanye's peak

BUT Kanye's lows > Eminem's lows

exactly

[King Lance]

Kanye has a more consistent discography than Eminem and it's undeniable. However, Em's best albums > Kanye's best albums

SSLP, MMLP, TES > Kanye's peak

BUT Kanye's lows > Eminem's lows

MBDTF is better than TES imo

[DanWS]

Of course it's arguable.