Is it arguable that Kanye West has a better disco than Em ?

[Trimss]

MBDTF is better than TES imo

mh arguable tbh. Won't shit on you for saying that

Late registration is kanyes best album.

how is that possible when MBDTF is the rap Thriller

eminem is the rap game mufasa and kanye is the rap game scar

[King Lance]

Kanye has a more consistent discography than Eminem and it's undeniable. However, Em's best albums > Kanye's best albums

SSLP, MMLP, TES > Kanye's peak

BUT Kanye's lows > Eminem's lows

MBDTF is better than TES imo

Should we ask Pitchfork what they think about that ?

You don't really want to go in that territory do you ?


no but seriously, I think that Eminem is a better rapper on tes than kanye is on mbdtf but mbdtf is overall a better album than tes.

With that said, SSLP & TMMLP > MBDTF imo

[TRSL]

Yes, Kanye has arguably the best discography in the rap game, although his last album isn't in line of the rest. Em has 1 extremely wack album and 2 'meh' ones. But yeah, Eminem in his peak era can't be topped by anyone.

[King Lance]

these people man

[Trimss]

rap game jackie chan

[Trimss]

i love trimss and he loves me

50 is most consistent

2 classics
2 great albums
ski will be classic
g-unit album classic
mixtapes classic

wow get out before we start making fun of you

[Jason M.]

Kanye has higher highs and lower lows. So it's really subjective.

[Krusty]

50 is most consistent

2 classics
2 great albums
ski will be classic
g-unit album classic
mixtapes classic

Lol ?

[Fleka]

Somebody here said that Kanye influenced more rappers than Eminem. I strongly disagree. Em lyrical skills made more rappers try harder and be more lyrical. The only thing where Kanye has influence is producing. I`m sorry, but Kanye will never be more than mediocre rapper with overprudced songs.

And MBDTF better than TES? Come on.

[Trimss]

Kanye has higher highs and lower lows. So it's really subjective.

That's because you don't truly realize Eminem's genius. You should listen to Em's first three again, back to back and then listen to Recovery. Maybe it'll click idk

wow its like you can read my mind

Hage you consider PotD and GRODT classics, right?

Truthfully, they are. Or at least they're very good. Massacre is okay, the rest is garbo

[Krusty]

50's short influence on the game:

[Trimss]

right off the bat, peep show

[King Lance]

name one song that isn't at least average

you know that's not really a good thing if the whole album is average with 2-3-4 great songs

classic album = one without skippable songs

not really, it's more like a personal classic for you because a song can only be good in your opinion.

I'd say that classic album = impact, influence, "quality" (album "considered" as a great album by a certain amount of people).

For example, Reasonable Doubt wasn't even considered as a 5/5 album in the 90's, critics & fans thought that it was just another good/great album but that same album started to influence other artists and it's now full of timeless songs.

[Trimss]

Hage 2far.

[King Lance]

not really, it's more like a personal classic for you.

I'd say that classic album = impact, influence, quality (album "considered" as a great album).

For example, Reasonable Doubt wasn't even considered as a 5/5 album in the 90's, critics & fans thought that it was just another good/great album but that same album started to influence other artists and it's now full of timeless songs.

50 dominated the early 2000's and influenced countless artists ( I believe even kendrick said he admires him ), the quality of all his albums is amazing and impact .. speaks for itself.

and I never said that Grodt wasn't a classic (& you can have the argument that potd is an underground classic)