Eminem could have created a classic in 2009

[Mr Change]

Get over it

[Mr Evil]

What an odd thread

[Ares]

2009 Em was the closest we will ever get to the prime Eminem. He had dope flow, production, everything.

[Josh]

The Warning is in my Top 50 Em Songs

He fucked Mariah twice after this

OP i agree Relapse was so underrated back in 09

[Him Shadow]

Whats it matter? He came in 2013 with an amazing supadupafly album with verses miles ahead of those 2 songs... (The Warning can compete, that song is amazing, but the other 2...)

this.

[ProdigalGe0]

In my opinion it was. And in your opinion maybe not. :/

that's the thing -- classics aren't about your personal opinion. you're misusing the term. if you think MMLP2 is the best album you've ever heard, that's an opinion that technically can't be deemed incorrect. nearly everyone on this planet, including 99.995% of stans, would disagree with you, but that opinion isn't provably false. MMLP2 is, however, not a classic and very unlikely to ever become one. that's fact

[Amadeo]

He was certainly on a roll with The Warning and Psycho.

The Warning is unreal. Sounds like he went back to 2001 for that song.

[Supershade]

Someone needs to fuck with Hailie or something to get him mad enough to make a Warning pt. 2

[Ares]

Someone needs to fuck with Hailie or something to get him mad enough to make a Warning pt. 2

Or Dre needs to get his ass off his billions and become part of Em's creative process again. It's been damn near 5 years since Relapse..... we need some more Dre and Em chemistry in our lives.

Dre too rich now to produce beats.

[Notalius]

Relapse is closer to being a cult classic than MMLP 2 is to being a classic

never said anything close to that though lol

MMLP2 is def not a classic

[Notalius]

OP, go back to ktt

I'm actually from SL haha

even worse

[ProdigalGe0]

OP, go back to ktt

I'm actually from SL haha

even worse

Was about to write that...damn

[shadyblogger]

I want the Bass Brothers back tbh

[ProdigalGe0]

I want the Bass Brothers back tbh

Me too bro...me too

[kkaniff]

I don't want anybody back, tbh.
What's done is done.
Bass Bros. made classic Em records.
Dre made classic Em records.
Luis Resto made classic Em records.
Rick Rubin has made classic Em records.
The only time I haven't liked Em's production choices was in Recovery, and I don't mind them so much now.
Like Em told the Bass Bros; he needs to experiment with new sounds, and I fully agree.