A Possible Eminem Show

[classthe_king]

Eminembase's comment yesterday and someone elses comment a couple weeks ago about No Apologies being an Eminem Show left over made me think about this album. Instead of having Drips, When The Music Stops, Business and Superman we get Renegade, No Apologies and Stimulate and then Lose Yourself as another single.

2. White America-8/10
3. Lose Yourself-10/10
4. Cleanin' Out My Closet-8/10
5. Square Dance-8/10
7. Soldier-9/10
8. Say Goodbye Hollywood-9/10
9. Renegade (Feat. Jay-Z)-10/10
10. Without Me-7/10
12. Sing for the Moment-10/10
13. No Apologies-9/10
14. Hailie's Song-8/10
16. Stimulate-9/10
17. Say What You Say (Feat. Dr. Dre)-7/10
18. Till I Collapse-9/10
19. My Dad's Gone Crazy-8/10

That would give it an 8.6/10 which by my standards is insanely high considering my Eminem show right now gets a 7.9 and I rank that a 10/10. Although this probably isn't possible I think it would forever be the undisputed greatest album ever just because of how many amazing songs are on it and the constant great songs.

[mcZu]

Taking out Say What You Say, making it 18 tracks long instead of 19 tracks would've been much better.

[classthe_king]

Taking out Say What You Say, making it 18 tracks long instead of 19 tracks would've been much better.

Yeah

That would have took out the only 7/10 besides the single. I bet if he had No Apologies and Stimulate though he probably would've had another high caliber track to replace it with though.

[nathan123]

Take out SGH and replace it with 8 mile road and that makes it th greatest album ever...

[ku53v]

I like the original version much better

[Bistnal]

That looks like one hell of an album. If you took out Say What You Say or replace with another 8 mile OST song or something that would be imo, a flawless album.

[MikeNUFC]

8 Mile songs don't make sense on the album though.

I mean he's rapping about the negativity of fame on TES, so songs about trying to get out the hood on there? Wouldn't make sense.

Plus Say What You Say & Business are brilliant.

Stimulate is amazing but it's too similar in terms of content with SFTM. (I prefer SFTM, too)

I agree about No Apologies instead of When The Music Stops, though. No Apologies following SFTM would be perfect.

[classthe_king]

8 Mile songs don't make sense on the album though.

I mean he's rapping about the negativity of fame on TES, so songs about trying to get out the hood on there? Wouldn't make sense.

Plus Say What You Say & Business are brilliant.

Stimulate is amazing but it's too similar in terms of content with SFTM. (I prefer SFTM, too)

I agree about No Apologies instead of When The Music Stops, though. No Apologies following SFTM would be perfect.

Actually, I see what you're saying with Lose Yourself but Stimulate was made for The Eminem Show so it can stay, even if it is similar to SFTM. It's still better then most of TES.

And I don't see how Business is genius? I find it boring besides a good chorus.

[classthe_king]

Drop Superman? Nahh.

Get rid of Say What You Say instead.

At first I had dropped Say What You Say but Eminembase convinced me to drop Superman instead.

[Elision]

How could TiC possibly be any better? 11/10 imo

[classthe_king]

How could TiC possibly be any better? 11/10 imo

You don't think taking out the worst 2 songs on the album and replacing it with Renegade and No Apologies would make it better

[Slim's Shady]

How could TiC possibly be any better? 11/10 imo

You don't think taking out the worst 2 songs on the album and replacing it with Renegade and No Apologies would make it better

LOL he was talking about Till I Collapse (TiC).

[classthe_king]

Why did I read that as TES

Touche

[Brood]

Right now I think MMLP is his best album, but adding those songs to TES could have possibly surpassed MMLP. No Apologies is by far my favorite Em song.

[momentisgolden]

I think it would forever be the undisputed greatest album ever just because of how many amazing songs are on it and the constant great songs.

But removing When the Music Stops would is wrong for me. I know u hate Bizzare so imma ask, how would u rate it if you remove his verse?!