Do you think Jay Z has an Album as good as

[Aftermathers]

The Slim Shady LP, The Marshall Mathers LP and The Eminem Show?

[Jdubem]

naw but i know a lot of fucks who would try and say he does. reasonable doubt is as close as it gets

[Aftermathers]

naw but i know a lot of fucks who would try and say he does. reasonable doubt is as close as it gets

Agreed with that he definitley doesnt and his closest Album to a classic is Reasonable Doubt but not a pure classic just a good Album and his best Album

[Amaranthine]

As good as all three combined?

[Trimss]

Won't you stop making threads?

[Jdubem]

idk reasonable doubt is probably still a classic imo, just not as good as ems haha.

[Aftermathers]

As good as all three combined?

No invidually does Jay Z have an Album as good as either The Slim Shady LP, The Marshall Mathers LP or The Eminem Show


Those Albums are classics and i think much superior to Jay Z's best Album Reasonable Doubt

[Aftermathers]

idk reasonable doubt is probably still a classic imo, just not as good as ems haha.

Yeah that's a fair point i can respect that view even if people do think it's a classic it's not touching Em's first 3 Albums


Reason i don't think Reasonable Doubt is a classic though is cos of Songs like Cshmere Thoughts, Ain't No etc which are too weak and also cos i don't think it has aged well as far as replay value which is an important factor in classics. I think because it's his best Album a lotta his fans wanted it to be but i think it's a good Album if you judge it properly on the lack of replay value and the weaker Songs.

[Emadyville]

no

[Blu]

This is the thing we don't like about you. You always go out your way to try and prove that Em is better than any other rapper.

I'd have to say The Blueprint is a great album, and definitely on the same tier as The Slim Shady LP.

[Stanforever]

Same song and dance

[EminemBase]

Nope.

[Jdubem]

man you all are really hating on this guy and he doesnt even have that many posts wtf

[shadymathers313]

Does he? Maybe, but not to most Em fans.
Jay has had a good run, he's made incredible music. Some consider him the best, which is why what you say is not a fact.

To me, he doesn't. But that's because his music isn't as appealing to me as Em's.

Jay doesnt appeal to me as much as Em either but hes still in my top 5 of all time.
his 3 albums Reasonable Doubt, Blueprint and The Black Album are his best if u want to compare them to SSLP, MMLP and TES.

I prefer all 3 of those Jay albums i named over TES but not better then SSLP or MMLP. but thats just me. its all about taste and what u like more. nothing else. they are all great albums

[ImHungry]

The Slim Shady LP, The Marshall Mathers LP and The Eminem Show?

No.