They gave The MMLP a 1.5 :D

[Table]

http://www.slantmagazine.com/music/revi ... hers-lp/63

Just came across this pathetic excuse for an album review.
After reinstating that a work of art is supposed to be judged solely on its intention, he goes on to throw tirades at the album's on purpose politically incorrect, crude, hypocritical and satirical (which he perceives as more accidental than deliberate) themes.

Questioning morality, rectitude, lack of maturity and aiming of one dimensional diatribes at the society in a blatantly obvious nihilist record? Tch tbh! When were raw human emotions supposed to be mature anyway? Maturity is just a mask we wear to look socially apt. Expecting Eminem to find a middle ground, wise man stand when the artist's ideology is clearly left field?
Art is an entity, whether the artist is immature in a real life context is immaterial to the discussion.
He seems to be lost finding insight in the face value of the content when the artist attentively avoids giving any.

The fact that this dude gets paid to write reviews saddens me
Did I tell you he gave The MMLP a 1.5 and Encore a 2.5?

[AbramIsaac]

Oh wow...

[PAINKILLƎR]

This guy is a fucking joke... Where's EmBase when you need him? I love his responses to these kind of reviews. He needs to grace this thread with his Base swag.

[CanadaPure]

Do we just say EminemBase like 3 times to summon him or something?

EminemBase, EminemBase, EminemBase.

[Table]

This article is from 2001 doe. This guy was probably a faggot.

They continue to hate on Eminem, though.
They gave recovery a 1.5 too although a different reviewer.

[Fleka]

"Stan" is an interesting look into the mind of a fanatic (albeit through the eyes of an equally disturbed individual), but it's structured entirely around someone else's work (Dido's "Thankyou").

At first the track "Kim" is gratuitously violent, but it's ultimately so absurd and campy that it's almost forgivable.

This guy is an idiot. Because, anybody could, after listening to "Thank You" make a song as great as Stan.

[SoldierShady]

Slant are a bunch of fudge nudgers. :

[Whitefox]

EminemBase, EminemBase, EminemBase.

[sbolli1]

"He's essentially hip-hop's houseguest and would never bite the nipple he suckles from."

I'm high and tired as shit and I still want to find a strangle this faggot

[Ticalrecords]

damn i just hope as a journalist he never even sees 0.0000000001 percent of the money eminem has.

""Who Knew" finds Eminem absolving himself of any social responsibility"

lmao, isn't that the overarching theme of the whole record? if your not on board with that, obviously your not gonna like the album

[Kill You]

Okay, opinions are opinions but this guy is just wrong and stupid.

[EminemBase]

Ridiculous.

"socially inept"... what a moron.

I've read reviews from these guys on EM before, they're clearly written by homosexual reactionaries who don't understand the music and go by hearsay, or just don't get it. Idiots.