Is it arguable that Kanye West has a better disco than Em ?

[fifflaren]

I just want to know your opinion, be objective please.

[SajN]

And here we go.

[Krusty]

I enjoy Eminem's albums more but you can have that argument.

He influenced the game, all his albums are critically acclaimed and most of his albums are in the discussions for classic albums.

[Norway kills]

I really like that Yeezus album; it's a breath of fresh air in a time while most other artists are playing it safe. My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy is also a very strong piece of work. The rest of his discography? Not feeling it.

All in all, Em is the king.

[King Lance]

he has one of the most consistent discographies in hip hop, so Yes.
Don't like Yeezus though

[Snakebeast]

Arguable, yes. Kanye is fucking awesome. (Fuck Cheezus doe)

[metsfan1121]

You're on the wrong forum to ask that. I'd say no way in hell but I honestly haven't even heard most of Kanye's stuff outside his radio hits, MBDTF, and about half of Yeezus.

[King Lance]

Oh, I gotcha.

I'll have a final answer when MMLP2 comes out, even before that though it's fairly close i'd say.

Well perhaps not, Eminem has classics. Kanye has some REALLY good albums but no classics.

If kanye doesn't have any classic then it's the same for Eminem.
2 of his albums went diamond and he influenced 2 or 3 artists like Earl, Tyler and Hopsin but what impact did his first albums have on this genre we call hip hop ?

they both have classic albums imo, Eminem's albums are more popular but I'd say that kanye's albums had a bigger impact on hip hop.

[ladelsofgravy]

kanye has an impressive discography, to be honest.

eminem is a much better rapper but less consistent than kanye

[Mr.DGAF]

I don't know. They both do rap, but Kanye's probably got a style closer to Disco than Em. I guess I'd give it to Kanye.

[PAINKILLƎR]

Kanye has no #kla$$ikz. Em has 3.

[Snakebeast]

I don't know. They both do rap, but Kanye's probably got a style closer to Disco than Em. I guess I'd give it to Kanye.

[King Lance]

Oh, I gotcha.

I'll have a final answer when MMLP2 comes out, even before that though it's fairly close i'd say.

Well perhaps not, Eminem has classics. Kanye has some REALLY good albums but no classics.

If kanye doesn't have any classic then it's the same for Eminem.
2 of his albums went diamond and he influenced 2 or 3 artists like Earl, Tyler and Hopsin but what impact did his first albums have on this genre we call hip hop ?

they both have classic albums imo, Eminem's albums are more popular but I'd say that kanye's albums had a bigger impact on hip hop.

I'd consider TCD and LR classics perhaps.

I like every song a whole lot, LR more so.

I know it's too soon to call mbdtf a certified classic but the album is definitely on his way to be labelled as a classic

[Raul]

In my opinion, Em has 4 classics (SSLP, MMLP, TES and Relapse)
Kanye has College Dropout, Graduation, 808 and MBDTF. Yeezus and Late Registration are better than Encore and Recovery, so...

Yes.

But MMLP>TES>College Dropout, so it's hard for me to cement my own opinion in myself.

[Mr.DGAF]

The word "classic" is thrown around so easy, seems like every artist discussed here has a "classic".