Why Relapse/Refill is better than MMLP2/Bonus

[Jimmy Conway]

Is it? I'm not sure.

I kind of think it might be.

MMLP2
1.GroundHog Day
2.Legacy
3.Rap God
4.Brainless
5.Evil Twin
6.Bad Guy
7.Headlights
8.Baby
9.Beautiful Pain
10.Stronger Than I Was
11.Monster
12.Rhyme or Reason
13.Berzerk
14.So Much Better
15.Desperation
16.Survival
17.Wicked Ways
18.So Far
19.Love Game
20.Asshole

Relapse

1.Buffalo Bill
2. 3 a.m
3. My Mom
4. Insane
5. Bagpipes from Baghdad
6. Hello
7. Elevator
8. Same Song & Dance
9. We Made You
10. Medicine Ball
11. Music Box
12. Stay Wide Awake
13. Old Time's Sake
14. Must Be the Ganja
15. My Darling
16. Déjà Vu
17. Beautiful
18. Crack a Bottle
19. Careful What You Wish For
20. Underground


I.....kind of think it's Relapse. But I also think the newness of the MMLP2 is making me unsure of that.

[superman11]

Never in a million years from me, just posted this on another thread. But I'd take anything MMLP2 brings to the table over anything from Encore up until this album.. Only thing that Relapse can rival it with is production, but I enjoy the diversity on MMLP2, and an album with Em, Dre and Rubin plus a few randoms would be amazing.. But yeah, and that's not cause it's new, I've listened to this album 10-15 times already and I'm still loving it every listen.

[superman11]

That track list you posted isn't Relapse.

And this too, lel.

[Kill You]

Eh idk. It may or may not be. I need more time with this album. But Eminem on this >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Jimmy Conway]

Is that Relapse list order from favourite to less favourite?
plztellmeitsnot inb4itis

No, I just copied the track list, took the skits out and put in other songs to make it 20.


I can't even say that the MMLP2 is in order. I don't know what my order is. It was just put together from another thread in a 20 song format and I'm lazy and it served the purpose to the quickly made thread.

[Kill You]

Yeah the way you have it makes Relapse look better.

[CanadaPure]

Why not compare the albums the way they were made? Doing that, it's MMLP2.

Because TR has this idea that albums are still the same album even if you make it into a completely different album.

Yep.

[Jimmy Conway]

The album I posted isn't the MMLP2 either.


I don't like leaving out songs from the same session when they are all there.

Just because they were put in a certain order means nothing to me.


The music is there, all that matters is the music.

A lot of politics go into track lists. I don't care about that.

Just the music.

[Jimmy Conway]

Are you petty hair splitting faggots happy now?

[superman11]

I'd still say no, no matter how you place the Relapse era versus these songs, it will lose for me.

[4Corners]

No. Even with the bonus stuff, MMLP2 is clearly better.

You act as if MMLP2 bonus cuts weren't dope.

[Jimmy Conway]

I like the MMLP2. I just think Relapse might be better.

You guys get into emotional Em a little more than I do. I enjoy it, but I also really like technical rapping.

I like the consistent flow he had on that album. Something I could just rap along to in my car and really get into.


Dre has always been good of giving him beats for him to crush.

I haven't listened to Relapse in while, but I'm sure when I hear Stay Wide Awake I'll be blown away like always.

I think me and Tyler the creator were the only two people to vote Relapse.

[trentimus]

Well, it's not Relapse, and it's not MMLP2 that you're comparing then. You're comparing songs from the time periods, not the actual CDs themselves. So the title of the thread is wrong.

I like the MMLP2. I just think Relapse might be better.

You guys get into emotional Em a little more than I do. I enjoy it, but I also really like technical rapping.

I like the consistent flow he had on that album. Something I could just rap along to in my car and really get into.


Dre has always been good of giving him beats for him to crush.

I haven't listened to Relapse in while, but I'm sure when I hear Stay Wide Awake I'll be blown away like always.

I think me and Tyler the creator were the only two people to vote Relapse.

I listened to MMLP2 and Relapse back to back.. I don't know that it is all that clear that MMLP2 is better than Relapse.

The production, lyrics and flow on Relapse are fucking bonkers.. For now I'll say MMLP2 = Relapse after my recent listening session.. I think in a year I will be saying Relapse >> MMLP2

[Mathers]

MMLP 2 >> Relapse and that won't change over time like Recovery.