The Slim Shady LP vs Reasonable Doubt

[dshady89]

I don't smoke crack Aftermathers.

Reasonable Doubt outshines The Slim Shady LP on a lyrical and production basis.

Jay's best, arguably one of Em's worst...

I know you like to troll son, but seriously, this was waaaay 2far.

Edit: Thread delivered tho.

[emin3m_stan]

Say Goodbye To Holywood = Produced by Eminem, Hook Sung by Eminem, Mixed by Eminem


Sing For The Moment = Produced by Eminem, Mixed by Eminem


Hailies Song = Sung by Eminem, Produced by Eminem, Mixed by Eminem


Not Afraid = Co Produced by Eminem, Hook sung by Eminem



Lose Yourself = Produced by Eminem, Hook done by Eminem, Mixed by Eminem



I could go on and on



Lose Yourself, Rock Bottom, If I Had = about poverty


Hailies Song, Mockingbird, When I'm Gone = about being a parent


Cleaning Out My Closet, Sing For The Moment = about living in a broken home


Mosh, White America, We As Americans = about politics



^^^^^ All them Produced, Mixed by Eminem too

Sing For The Moment was produced by Aerosmith you queer

and he had alot of help by Resto, and Dre mixing and producing those

the fuck is wrong with you?

It was produced by Eminem so your the fucking queer, the song was sampled from Aerosmiths 'Dream On' so what a bitch you just sounded.

[Kill You]

Pink Friday: Roman Reloaded

[TheGentlePlayer]

SSLP cuz Em is best!

[Manly Moose]

Fact Rock Bottom, If I Had, 97 Bonnie & Clyde>>>>any Jay Z song the Lyrics, Production, replay value on SSLP is much better

The lyrics are better on Reasonable Doubt and so is production. Also, you put If I Had on your list??? Good song but anything on RD outshines it. SSLP is a good album but the songs become very monotonous in the 2nd half and seem it all seems very meaningless compared to RD.

I know Blu is just trolling but he has some points, the biggest being that some people here put Em on too high a pedestal. Ems classic period is great, if you think no artist comes close you need to spend more time listening to other artists. I mean some people here actually think Reasonable Doubt is boring which is understandable if your not listening to the lyrics or need booming dre bass to satisfy to keep your attention. I guess some people dont understand the art of being subtle.


EDIT: Wow I responded before I knew just how bad this thread was. Great potential for real discussion here, instead we have flame war between opposing stans.

[Man1x]

Eminem owned Shady Records by himself from 1999 up till now


Jay Z was a part owner of Rocafella from 1996 - 2004 with Dame Dash and biggz being the other 2 owners


Eminem owned Shady LTD clothing by himself


Jay Z was a part owner of Rocawear with Dame and Biggz

Paul has always been a co-owner of Shady Records. He has always had more stock. Also, Shady's clothing line failed horribly...#NoPointMade

Edit: Anyway, I choose The Slim Shady LP even though Reasonable Doubt isn't bad at all, it's fucking amazing. You could easily argue for it being better, I made opinion on what I like more.

By the way, fuck you Aftermathers. Blu da GOAT.

[EminemBase]

Easily The Slim Shady LP for me, but Reasonable Doubt is good.

[Almostlity]

Is an Oscar award winning Actor

That Oscar he won has NOTHING to do with his ''acting''

[MikeNUFC]

Reasonable Doubt's great but SSLP is the GOAT.

[radioactivejaber]

Who said it's about sales?

2pac has less sales than Em does that make him any worse of a rapper?

Shut up bruh, Em is a failure, was only good when he was rappin about rapin his moms tbh.

i was on your side up until you said Em is a failure. In no sense of the term is a failure lol. He's successful, been a relatively good father (i say that in reservation, as he as kept his kids out of the public eye) and has made great music for a decade. He's gotten out of drug addiction and come back to being an incredibly formidable rapper that no one dares fuck with. He's influenced rap in ways that people can dream.

[radioactivejaber]

Pink Friday: Roman Reloaded

[Man1x]

Who said it's about sales?

2pac has less sales than Em does that make him any worse of a rapper?

Shut up bruh, Em is a failure, was only good when he was rappin about rapin his moms tbh.

i was on your side up until you said Em is a failure. In no sense of the term is a failure lol. He's successful, been a relatively good father (i say that in reservation, as he as kept his kids out of the public eye) and has made great music for a decade. He's gotten out of drug addiction and come back to being an incredibly formidable rapper that no one dares fuck with. He's influenced rap in ways that people can dream.

He's trolling Afterphaggit....

[radioactivejaber]

Jay-Z is a GOAT. But Reasonable Doubt is not his best album, and neither is SSLP.

Jay Z
1. The Blueprint 10/10
2. The Black Album 10/10
3. Reasonable Doubt 9/10
4. American Gangster 9/10

Eminem
1. The Eminem Show 10/10
2. MMLP 10/10
3. Relapse 10/10
4. SSLP 9/10

[radioactivejaber]

Who said it's about sales?

2pac has less sales than Em does that make him any worse of a rapper?

Shut up bruh, Em is a failure, was only good when he was rappin about rapin his moms tbh.

i was on your side up until you said Em is a failure. In no sense of the term is a failure lol. He's successful, been a relatively good father (i say that in reservation, as he as kept his kids out of the public eye) and has made great music for a decade. He's gotten out of drug addiction and come back to being an incredibly formidable rapper that no one dares fuck with. He's influenced rap in ways that people can dream.

He's trolling Afterphaggit....

whats an "Afterphaggit"?

[Man1x]

Check backstage threads