Who do you think has a better catalouge Eminem vs Jay Z?

[Aftermathers]

I think Eminem's first 3 Albums The Slim Shady LP, The Marshall Mathers LP, The Eminem Show are better than any Jay Z Album.

I think The SSLP, The MMLP and The Eminem Show are classic Albums which you can play from start to finish with out skipping a track. I think they are better than Jay Z's good Albums like Reasonable Doubt for this reason as well as Musically they are so much more diverse and enjoyable with much better Song Writting, Production and range of topics. Basically having every type of Hip Hop Song on them and superior replay value.


I think Reasonable Doubt is Jay Z's best Album and biggest achievement of his career and is a good Mafasio type Album and the best aspect is Jay Z's Flow on the Album.

[Chet Starr]

You have constantly made topic after topic about how much you dislike Jay-Z, day after day.

Go outside, forget about Jay. Listen to some music you enjoy. Smile

It's an eminem forum, of course he wins.