Which Rapper has the best catalouge of albums ever?

[Coast2Coast]

What Artist has the best catalouge?

[Coast2Coast]

Gotta be Eminem classic albums The slim Slim Shady LP, The Marshall Mathers LP, The Eminem Show and potentially Recovery

[Accor]

TERRIBLE list.

[Mathers]

Eminem.

[Coast2Coast]

Eminem.

[EminemBase]

Em's first three are the three GOAT successive albums. They're all classics in their own right, all individual mammoths but also build on the previous perfectly. A trio masterpiece.

[Coast2Coast]

Em's first three are the three GOAT successive albums. They're all classics in their own right, all individual mammoths but also build on the previous perfectly. A trio masterpiece.

Agreed no rapper has ever made an album as good as The Eminem Show or The marshall Mathers LP and The Eminem Show is 1 of the best produced albums ever so as a producer Eminem also produced 1 of the finest produced albums in hip hop's history

[DƎRDYPK]

Which rapper on this list do you like the least? That's who has the best catalogue.

that's right, HOV!

[Coast2Coast]

Eminembase aside from Eminem's first 3 albums which are all not just classics but some the best albums ever Recovery could have been a classic if it had the classic production The Eminem Show did

[King Lance]

Eminembase aside from Eminem's first 3 albums which are all not just classics but some the best albums ever Recovery could have been a classic if it had the classic production The Eminem Show did

recovery has sold approximately +4 million copies ( only in the us), so the album can have a lot of hate on this forum, a new public thinks that the album is a classic
So no one here can say that recovery isn't a classic, it's really subjective but people can say that the album is a classic as much as TES or TMMLP jsut by looking at the number of copies eminem has sold !
For the rest, it's all about opinions and different musical tastes, you need to remember that there is a world outside of this forum
Of course people are going to say I'm wrong or that recovery sucks, but that doesn't mean anything

I don't think its a classic album, but for a new public ( and a LARGE public), it is !..

we have to respect the artists who work so hard to release an album, we can give an opinion, but that's all, if recovery isn't a classic by the end of the decade, then we can't say that TES is a classic album, I mean, it's all about opinions and the public is really different except for the fans who decided to buy the albums

try to find a classic album with only 3 copies in the world (it depends on a lot of factors like the genre, the original public, but I believe that sometimes, the number of sales is really important tbh)

[Coast2Coast]

Eminembase aside from Eminem's first 3 albums which are all not just classics but some the best albums ever Recovery could have been a classic if it had the classic production The Eminem Show did

recovery has sold approximately +4 million copies ( only in the us), so the album can have a lot of hate on this forum, a new public thinks that the album is a classic
So no one here can say that recovery isn't a classic, it's really subjective but people can say that the album is a classic as much as TES or TMMLP jsut by looking at the number of copies eminem has sold !
For the rest, it's all about opinions and different musical tastes, you need to remember that there is a world outside of this forum
Of course people are going to say I'm wrong or that recovery sucks, but that doesn't mean anything

I don't think its a classic album, but for a new public ( and a LARGE public), the album is a classic...

we have to respect the artists who work so hard to release an album, we can give an opinion, but that's all, if recovery isn't a classic by the end of the decade, then we can't say that TES is a classic album, I mean, it's all about opinions

True to me cos i play it so much cos it so heart felt and i can feel it personally i love it

[Cube23]

Jay-Z.

[EminemBase]

Eminembase aside from Eminem's first 3 albums which are all not just classics but some the best albums ever Recovery could have been a classic if it had the classic production The Eminem Show did

recovery has sold approximately +4 million copies ( only in the us), so the album can have a lot of hate on this forum, a new public thinks that the album is a classic
So no one here can say that recovery isn't a classic, it's really subjective but people can say that the album is a classic as much as TES or TMMLP jsut by looking at the number of copies eminem has sold !
For the rest, it's all about opinions and different musical tastes, you need to remember that there is a world outside of this forum
Of course people are going to say I'm wrong or that recovery sucks, but that doesn't mean anything

I don't think its a classic album, but for a new public ( and a LARGE public), it is !..

we have to respect the artists who work so hard to release an album, we can give an opinion, but that's all, if recovery isn't a classic by the end of the decade, then we can't say that TES is a classic album, I mean, it's all about opinions and the public is really different except for the fans who decided to buy the albums

try to find a classic album with only 3 copies in the world (it depends on a lot of factors like the genre, the original public, but I believe that sometimes, the number of sales is really important tbh)

Classics aren't judged by sales, if they were then NSync's albums would be masterpieces.

[King Lance]

Eminembase aside from Eminem's first 3 albums which are all not just classics but some the best albums ever Recovery could have been a classic if it had the classic production The Eminem Show did

recovery has sold approximately +4 million copies ( only in the us), so the album can have a lot of hate on this forum, a new public thinks that the album is a classic
So no one here can say that recovery isn't a classic, it's really subjective but people can say that the album is a classic as much as TES or TMMLP jsut by looking at the number of copies eminem has sold !
For the rest, it's all about opinions and different musical tastes, you need to remember that there is a world outside of this forum
Of course people are going to say I'm wrong or that recovery sucks, but that doesn't mean anything

I don't think its a classic album, but for a new public ( and a LARGE public), it is !..

we have to respect the artists who work so hard to release an album, we can give an opinion, but that's all, if recovery isn't a classic by the end of the decade, then we can't say that TES is a classic album, I mean, it's all about opinions and the public is really different except for the fans who decided to buy the albums

try to find a classic album with only 3 copies in the world (it depends on a lot of factors like the genre, the original public, but I believe that sometimes, the number of sales is really important tbh)

Classics aren't judged by sales, if they were then NSync's albums would be masterpieces.

I agree with you but classics aren't judged only by personal opinion neither :/
Just wanted to point out that sales can show how big a public can loooooovoe an album.
Wanted to explain that this is not because the half of trshady doesn't like recovery that recovery isn't a classic (used to read ppl here who believed that recovery was shit only because a lot of people from THIS forum didn't like it )
In fact, I think sales is really important to judge if the album is a classic or not, but as I said, there are a lot of things to consider such as the genre, the original public, if the artist is independant or not ect

bigpray said exactly what I tried to say with the sales !
eminem touched a different public and yep, some pop fans really believe that recovery is a classic in his genre.

The beetles's albums are classic but we, as hip hop fans, don't really like them :/

[King Lance]

^ lol I was talking about the Nsync pop fans think Nsync has classics

yep but you said exactly what I wanted to say about recovery, so its all cool
but agree with you too about Nsync

btw man, what kind of dog is it ? at first, I really thought it was a baby American staff
Don't hate on me, I don't rly know anything special about dogs lol