difficult question most will get wrong

[Damarkus]

You die you go to a room with two identical doors with indentical guards, one guards the door to heaven the other to hell, you have to choose your door and your only alowed to ask one question. the man gaurding heaven always tells the truth and the man gaurding hell allways tells a lie. what question do you ask?

they have no prior knoledge to you so you can be like is my name or take a dog and say is this a dog if you get me

[UzaKING]

Ask one of them would the other guard say you tell the truth?

the lying one would say yes
the truthfull one would say no

[Solace]

^How come I sat and stared at this topic for like 5 minutes and couldn't think of that.

[Damarkus]

forgot to mention that what i mean by prior knoledge is that they know nothing of each other just that they are gaurding a door

[UzaKING]

K.. ask one of them to point at the door they are guarding then the liar wont point to the door hes infront of

[Damarkus]

not really a question with an answer tho thats like holding 4 fingers up saying how many am i holding upthe gaurd only knows about the door

[UzaKING]

k......
i would ask

would you say yes if someone asked you if this is the door to heaven?

the liar would say no
the other would say yes

and they only know about the door so that question would work

[kevinh]

is the other guard guardening a door?

[UzaKING]

is the other guard guardening a door?

no i dont think hes a farmer

[Drama Setter]

k......
i would ask

would you say yes if someone asked you if this is the door to heaven?

the liar would say no
the other would say yes

and they only know about the door so that question would work

But you don't know which one goes to the heaven or hell

[UzaKING]

k......
i would ask

would you say yes if someone asked you if this is the door to heaven?

the liar would say no
the other would say yes

and they only know about the door so that question would work

But you don't know which one goes to the heaven or hell

I wouldnt? did you not read the first post

the man gaurding heaven always tells the truth and the man gaurding hell allways tells a lie

[Solace]

would you say yes if someone asked you if this is the door to heaven?

Yeah that would work

[Epidemik]

ask either guard, what door would the OTHER guard tell me leads to heaven, and then do the opposite.

cuz if you asked the truthful guard what door the other guard will tell you leads to heaven, he would tell you the truth and say the door that leads to hell

if you asked the liar what door the other guard would choose, he would lie and tell you that the truthful guard would tell you to choose the door that leads to hell.

so no matter who you ask, just ask what the OTHER guard would tell you leads to heaven, then choose the opposite door.

[UzaKING]

ask either guard, what door would the OTHER guard tell me leads to heaven, and then do the opposite.

I allready said one like that and he said they only know about theyre door and nothing else

[Epidemik]

well then thats just gay