if em quits...

[Mr. Cookie]

Em and Proof started D-12...

No, hell no...D-12 will not fall apart if Em quits...

[Speech]

em and proof did i thought d12 was a grou which couldnt get filled afta bugz died so em sjoined d12 later on?
well.....

[missslimshady]

if em quits they can't be d12 no longer

[A Chicago Thing]

I have seen in mulitple places that swift replaced bugz. I have also seen mulitple places it was eminem.

anyway, the songs without eminem are not stronger. And proof is not better, maybe before when they were both unsigned hype but hip hop shop and search for jerry garcia were ass.

[link shady]

bugz wanted swift in so he was in
and eminem joined after bugz dead it is like that

[$0 R3@L]

we've had this discussion over and over....PROOF IS HAND DOWNS BETTER THEN EMINEM!!!

eminem and d12 is stronger but even without eminem they are still strong.The only people who fink different are groupie eminem fans who wouldnt touch a d12 album unless eminem is there -_-

[$0 R3@L]

sarah, i promise you had d12 never even been associated with eminem they would have half the fans as they do now.Whether thats due to eminem groupies??? white teen girls and boys???? who knows but thats pure fact.

[A Chicago Thing]

we've had this discussion over and over....PROOF IS HAND DOWNS BETTER THEN EMINEM!!!

eminem and d12 is stronger but even without eminem they are still strong.The only people who fink different are groupie eminem fans who wouldnt touch a d12 album unless eminem is there -_-

no no no no - listen to Search for Jerry Garcia or I miss the hip hop shop. None of these hold a candle to any of eminem solo lps. I thought everyone sucked equally on D12 World but Devils Nights had some tracks where Swifty or Proof could of carried the songs without Em.

[A Chicago Thing]

You sayin that all the tracks on D12 sucked? Cos I thought that they were all really good.

screachin these chicks dont know the name of my band with bannafanna nanna blaaaaah. no didn't like it, i like Devils Night rawer sound. I did like "how come" - finally got to heard em touch on the Royce Nickel Nine beef.

[A Chicago Thing]

But did you listen to em' cos of Em or what?

Devils Night? Yes. D12 World? No. I wanted to hear kon artist beats and swifty and proof lyrics. And finally to see what direction eminem was heading with his career. I was a little harsh, there are a couple good songs on the album, but I was severely dissappointed with it. Like D12 World and Encore I think taint the images of D12/Eminem soooo much. But I guess D12 World actually sold and gave D12 money which is good. (Devils Night came out a little before 9/11 and there best single Fight Music was going to be released in september but they opted against it for obvious reasons)

[tamara]

maybe..lets wait and see

[Mr. Cookie]

what the fuck y'all sayin'? D-12 World sucks? you been brainwashed...Devil's Night and D-12 World are good..

[A Chicago Thing]

what the fuck y'all sayin'? D-12 World sucks? you been brainwashed...Devil's Night and D-12 World are good..

brainwashed? because it did well on TRL does not make it a good album. Please, it's not like i'm running around sayin listen to infinite you herd of sheep. It was a BAD album, or maybe it's just my absolute distaste for Bizarre as a rapper. Who knows?

[MCRounce]

D12 world and devils night are both just super!!!!!!!!!
d12 rulez! all of them!

[Jay-19]

I don't think they will fall apart.