Encore is BETTER than The Marshall Mathers LP

[BrownyGee]

Yeah I said it. I don't care what anybody says. I prefer Encore over MMLP. Why? Most of the MMLP he is just talking about how controversial he is, killing his wife, bashing pop stars, raping his mom, hating faggots etc. In all honesty I really don't see why people like it so much. Encore he talks touches on more diverse issues. Politics, rap beefs, his kids, his love life, racist tape he made. It just seems like he is more mature. Yes I know a lot of the songs (My First Single, Big Weenie,) are childish but you have to realize that 3 of the man's songs leaked. If Ricky Ticky Toc, We As Americans, and Love You More were on the album instead of songs like Big Weenie, My First Single, and Ass Like That (I personally love ALT.) People would think differently of it. The Same way Relapse would be better if it had those bonus tracks instead of songs like My Mom and Must Be The Ganja

[mceddie]

[dR3]

Hahahaha.


*Walks out and expects a 10-paged thread by the end of the day.

[RapName]

[flyingmonkey10]

:laughing:

[EminemBase]

The Marshall Mathers LP isn't just 'about' those things. You obviously don't understand why it's considered the modern masterpiece it is.

It's a rolled up fireball of subversion, wit, extreme self-expression, personal turmoil. A constant mesh of character hopping, persona-juggling, psychological probing, social commentary. He's not just 'bashing pop stars' okay, in that album he embodies an entire era, pokes fun at it, repulses it... I mean, there's so much going on. His sense of irony on that album is just sublime.

I actually consider The Eminem Show his best album but I can absolutely see why MMLP is as highly regarded as it is and perhaps maybe even should be held as his true magnum opus until he creates something more 'important'. I feel TES is a better album but MMLP is just such a powerhouse, such a single-visioned but totally skizo experience of lyrical genius.

Where as Encore was a mixed bag. It was him not knowing which part of himself should be the most dominant, trying to please everybody and ending up with an arrangement that looks more like a mixtape than an album formation. It has some high points and I consider it a good album overall but my goodness not even close to MMLP.

You're probably just slimsoxshady in disguise though, trying to start a 200 page debate and will end up going "haha another successful troll" with a little gay beer emoticon after about 50 pages.

[GoodGirlsGetGutted]

I wouldn't necessarily say it's better, but I prefer it over the MMLP, personally.

[BrownyGee]

Hahahaha.


*Walks out and expects a 10-paged thread by the end of the day.

Hate all you want, but you know it's true MMLP sucks

[BrownyGee]

I wouldn't necessarily say it's better, but I prefer it over the MMLP, personally.

THANK YOU. Finally someone who doesn't think I'm crazy for saying this...

[BrownyGee]

I wouldn't necessarily say it's better, but I prefer it over the MMLP, personally.

THANK YOU. Finally someone who doesn't think I'm crazy for saying this...

youre still crazy for thinking its better overall

So I'm crazy for having an opinion? I don't know where you live but I live in America and in America we have something called FREEDOM of SPEECH.

[GoodGirlsGetGutted]

I wouldn't necessarily say it's better, but I prefer it over the MMLP, personally.

THANK YOU. Finally someone who doesn't think I'm crazy for saying this...

I saw you defending Evil Deeds.
I knew you'd come around.

I do love how icy and minimalist Encore is.

[buffalo bill]

Troll or literally insane, what is it?

[BrownyGee]

The Marshall Mathers LP isn't just 'about' those things. You obviously don't understand why it's considered the modern masterpiece it is.

It's a rolled up fireball of subversion, wit, extreme self-expression, personal turmoil. A constant mesh of character hopping, persona-juggling, psychological probing, social commentary. He's not just 'bashing pop stars' okay, in that album he embodies an entire era, pokes fun at it, repulses it... I mean, there's so much going on. His sense of irony on that album is just sublime.

I actually consider The Eminem Show his best album but I can absolutely see why MMLP is as highly regarded as it is and perhaps maybe even should be held as his true magnum opus until he creates something more 'important'. I feel TES is a better album but MMLP is just such a powerhouse, such a single-visioned but totally skizo experience of lyrical genius.

Where as Encore was a mixed bag. It was him not knowing which part of himself should be the most dominant, trying to please everybody and ending up with an arrangement that looks more like a mixtape than an album formation. It has some high points and I consider it a good album overall but my goodness not even close to MMLP.

You're probably just slimsoxshady in disguise though, trying to start a 200 page debate and will end up going "haha another successful troll" with a little gay beer emoticon after about 50 pages.

I just can't vibe with most of the Marshall Mathers LP. The production was horrid.

[Lokito4]

LOL and look at his avatar

[BrownyGee]

Troll or literally insane, what is it?

Neither just a man with an opinion