I will now be stating a fact...

[Kez]

The Apple is a song that could have been good, but you can tell when Em was writing it he just got bored and lost the concept halfway through, so it didn't turn out as well as it could have.

[Graphic]

I like GOAT.

[randomgirl]

I think I'm the only person alive who likes most of Encore, lol. Yes I enjoy My First Single, Rain Man, Puke, and Ass Like That. OMG! lol. I wouldn't say MFS was the worse song of his career, I can think of 5 songs that are way worse, lol. And FACK is extremely bizarre, but it is catchy and it's actually a funny song, to me, lol.

[randomgirl]

The five you named are definitely the stronger points of the album, I agree with that. I'd add in Mockingbird, Encore [the song], and One Shot 2 Shot as a few more stronger songs. But idk, I enjoy most of the album honestly. Even Just Lose It. Crazy in Love and Big Weenie are two songs that I never ever ever ever want to hear again.

[xxTrigger1989xx]

The Apple shits all over Encore.

[Fiftys_Advocate]

Encore Eminem > 2010-2011 Eminem

[Elision]

Disagree. You stated an opinion, not a fact. Faggot.

Dude you have no right to post after that shit about Em lying in JDGAF.

[M15HKA]

I actually agree with this, I like songs from 06-07 more than songs from the Encore era.
Public Enemy, Ricky Ticky Toc, The Apple, GOAT > Yellow Brick Road, Mockingbird, Like Toy Soldiers, When I'm Gone

u mad?

Aye bro isn't Ricky Ticky Tock an Encore Bonus Track..?

From 04-07 I think the only verses I actually liked were Spend Some Time,How Come,Yellow Brick Road(I think it was the last verse but the song in general is ok) When my brother showed me the straight from the lab ep I remember hearing We As Americans and he said it was obvious because of tracks like Square Dance on TES that he may go into a political phase, yeah guess he was wrong...lol I think it would have been dope if he went that route.(Public Enemy/Mosh/We As Americans/Square Dance I Enjoy the message in them even if they recorded in different years and Public Enemy doesn't even rhyme halfway through the track lol).

I don't like any of his verses 06-07. Unless I am forgetting something? The Straight from the Vault EP was horrific

@ Menzo yeah agree mate the start to Encore is tolerable, it is as though you can tell when he stopped giving a shit just after the Mosh track.

[VenomBlackViper]

I actually agree with this, I like songs from 06-07 more than songs from the Encore era.
Public Enemy, Ricky Ticky Toc, The Apple, GOAT > Yellow Brick Road, Mockingbird, Like Toy Soldiers, When I'm Gone

u mad?

Aye bro isn't Ricky Ticky Tock an Encore Bonus Track..?

Yup I just recently found that out though, I swear the whole time I was listening to Ricky Ticky Toc I thought it was from the Re-Up because of his voice/flow/subject matter. Then when I went to Wikipedia to check some shit on Encore I saw the bonus tracks & was like
You gotta admit it does sound like it's from the Re-Up era.

[Master Chief]

The Apple is an absolutely terrible song. The fact that the majority of his fans like that piece of shit and hate a well-written song like LTWYL makes me weep for Eminem.

1/3 of this post is very correct.

[M15HKA]

The Apple is an absolutely terrible song. The fact that the majority of his fans like that piece of shit and hate a well-written song like LTWYL makes me weep for Eminem.

This
LTWYL was very well written IMO, never understood the love for any of those Straight from the Vault leaks. Although I do not play LTWYL or any Straight for the vault tracks. Sometimes I think it is good Em stays away from twitter/ reading youtube as he may be influenced in a negative way.(Although I believe he is lying when he says he does not check stuff out on the net)

[Mahmoud48]

Encore eminem was more focused but he was being goofy
2007 eminem was just drugged outta his mind

[Asd-ONE]

Disagree. You stated an opinion, not a fact. Faggot.

Dude you have no right to post after that shit about Em lying in JDGAF.

Aight first of all, dude, you have no right to post with that avatar, nahimean?

Secondly, dude, that was obviously a troll thread and unfortunately got caught early, wasn't well hidden admittedly. It was pretty obvious, but I guess I trolled you, right? Wow. Talk about naive.

[zedzero27]

Second verse, he crams a personal anecdote into it, and the rhymes and flow fall apart, completely. He even tries to rhyme "relatives" with "pictures" and "sister" with "window." The rhymes that aren't forced are crappy. Flow makes this verse unlistenable.

well, thank god somebody finally said it.

[Rollimeo]

I liked the 50 ways songs from that period probably one of the few songs I play from that period