Why Sadistik is better than current Eminem

[Unscarred]

First off, why's there always got to be this dichotomy of 'winning' and 'losing', on the internet? It aint cool man, no one is right here, and no one is wrong - we are dealing with opinions. If Class likes Sadistik more than current Em then that is alright. It just means he takes more from Sadistik's music and appreciates it more than Eminem's. With any piece of art though, you can't quantify it and say that anything is better than anything else. I think you press this on people too much, Class. Like you're a bit hard-headed and have too much ego. People might be more open to appreciating the music that you like if you didn't shove it down their throats. Or maybe you are just trolling or whatever, and you and Satire and the rest of of your little cool internet clique find it funny antagonising people who like Eminem.

P.S I think Em and Sadistik are both very good rappers.

Best post in this thread.

[GenePeer]

^ lol, except the EP released a couple of years after still sounded the same.

He's had 18 tracks that sound the same TO YOU and Relapse had 17 tracks.
You know why it's okay that he sounds the same? Because no one else is doing what he's doing.
"Less creative version of Mac Lethal" my ass. Just because they occupy the same vague underground genre and are both "conscious rappers" does not mean they are similar at all.

Never called him a less creative version of mac lethal. In fact, I prefer him to mac lethal and I really do like his stuff.

It's not about the number of tracks, but the time difference in between the tracks. The songs released by an artist 2 or more years after his debut must really be told apart since he's still 'at the beginning' i.e. more ideas to play with. But in his case, that EP could easily be left-over tracks from when he made Balancing Act. If Eminem started sounding the same now, I'll just say it's time for him to retire. He played his part, and all his albums have shown evolution (and devolution in some). SSLP & MMLP were just a year apart and look at how he changed!

As for him being the only one doing what he's doing, it would be ok for him to do tracks that sound the same every once in a while. But there's gotta be variety.

Maybe it's not his fault, but the producer's.

[GenePeer]

^ lol, except the EP released a couple of years after still sounded the same.

I genuinely felt there was a massive difference between the album and the ep, felt like there was a big shift...maybe it's just me, lol.

or maybe it's just me. I seem to be the only one who thinks they sound the same.

[Alex2012]

[Robbie G]

The Art of Dying is a lot darker/ stranger than the Balancing Act. But it's still similar music and I agree that as he progresses he needs to be more diverse.