There is a major hypocrisy within this movement. Clearly from the site, the motive is to allow Em to step (back) into his creative regime where he produces those poignant, conceptually untouchable, tracks such as Stan, '97 Bonnie and Clyde et al.
However, these 'fans' are hammering at Em to move his music into their own direction. It's not natural or organic, it's plain bullying.
'Eminem, you wait until we meet up again, fucker we're kicking your ass for everything you've recently said' is what this movement reads to me (scuse the pun). Yes, he has produced some awful music, but as fans you can't bully an artist to change direction. You can let him know that you dislike his music, but simultaneously there will be fans who may like the music. What gives a certain group of people the right to make themselves out to be the numero-uno fans? To anyone who lacks a fucking brain, clearly a lot of people, these are rhetorical questions.
When Em jumps on mixtapes,or albums, he lets himself go creatively. The content of his music is one thing, but he is always in a process of change and experimentation. Music for him is his art; it's a hobby, for personal fulfillment.
In my opinion, the best thing that can happen from this is for Em to flip the three and the third at these 'fans' and show how he really does not give a fuck. What would happen then? Would they be happy he was back to not giving a shit? Probably not. Some people will never be happy. Allow people to exercise their freedom of speech to whatever degree, but in the process don't assume you speak for everyone.
I would love to talk to Em and explain how much I'd prefer to hear his flows, voice, lyrical content etc from the SSLP/MMLP, but that just won't happen. As an artist, we'd be 'lucky' if he went back to an older flow for a whole album; as artistically he'd be going down a reactionary, rather than evolutionary, path.
Considering the events in his life, we are lucky to be hearing music from him as it is.