Do you think The Eminem Show is

[Fleka]

I love SSLP, but MMLP and TES are in a special category. I think those two albums are better than SSLP.

[Aftermathers]

The Eminem Show>>>>>The MMLP>>>>>>>>Recovery>>>>>The SSLP

[Fleka]

The Eminem Show>>>>>The MMLP>>>>>>>>Recovery>>>>>The SSLP

SSLP is better than Recovery.

[Aftermathers]

I think Recovery is better

[Kill You]

The Eminem Show>>>>>The MMLP>>>>>>>>Recovery>>>>>The SSLP

SSLP is better than Recovery.

Not to him...he's not the only one with this view either. I see it a lot.

[Aftermathers]

The Eminem Show>>>>>The MMLP>>>>>>>>Recovery>>>>>The SSLP

SSLP is better than Recovery.

Not to him...he's not the only one with this view either. I see it a lot.

It depends on what people enjoy if you enjoy Substance and relating to Music speaking on real shit then people gonna say Recovery cos they like Deep Music


If you enjoy the crazy psycho comedy type Music then people gonna say THe Slim Shady LP


However Rock Bottom and If I Had are better than a lotta tracks on Recovery i feel but those are the type of Songs on there with a Deep Message

[Almostlity]

F.CK YOU AND YOUR SUBSTANCE.

[Aftermathers]

Suck ya mother

[Mathers]

The Eminem Show>>>>>The MMLP>>>>>>>>The SSLP>>>>>Recovery

Fixed.

[Cupid Stunt]

I hope Jeff Foxworthy makes a game show called: "Are you an Eminem dickrider?" then Aftermathers would win 1 million every time.

[Kill You]

A real Stan likes everything Eminem does. Not just one aspect of his music.

[Aftermathers]

Exactly a stan blindly supports everything Eminem does but i honestly do not like that Shock stuff.

[Almostlity]

I hope Jeff Foxworthy makes a game show called: "Are you an Eminem dickrider?" then Aftermathers would win 1 million every time.

Aftermathers doesn't like the Slim Shady stuff though, so he can't be a real Eminem dickrider.

Maybe it has something to with Emotional substance of Emotional substances substance substance?

Or Substances substance with goofy Emotional substance music.

[Cupid Stunt]

I hope Jeff Foxworthy makes a game show called: "Are you an Eminem dickrider?" then Aftermathers would win 1 million every time.

Aftermathers doesn't like the Slim Shady stuff though, so he can't be a real Eminem dickrider.

Oh, well, I was joking.

[EminemBase]

SSLP, MMLP, TES > all albums in the discographies of those artists, so that means Eminem Discography > those artist's discography

not to mention Recovery and Relapse are massive albums as well

Eminem is the best rapper in history, I just don't see how someone can argue otherwise :/ o well, too each their own

The Slim Shady LP is not better than Illmatic or Reasonable Doubt. You may like it more. But to state it's better is just simply incorrect.

The Slim Shady LP is more inventive, innovative, entertaining and original than those albums combined. Both Illmatic and Reasonable Doubt are classics, and obviously great albums. And, whichever anybody likes best out of the three, is preference...

But, I'd love to see somebody try and argue how Illmatic or Reasonable Doubt are superior in artistic terms. And yes, I do believe that is an argument that can be had with some logic and sense, and I think points can be made and scored in a sense. If we're talking... creativity and artistry.

If we're talking about what we prefer musically, the conversation is aimless. But artistically - The Slim Shady LP towers above those albums.

Jay and Nas tackle pretty basic themes on those albums. It's their execution which makes the music interesting. And with Illmatic especially, the praise was mostly upon its stylistic brilliance. And whilst execution can be everything, in terms of if something works or not...

On The Slim Shady LP, Em tackles... bundles more topics in bundles of more interesting ways. Beyond that he's got one of the most genius and most brilliantly executed concept tracks EVER on it ("97 Bonnie and Clyde")... I mean, that track alone (never mind the album) is miles more interesting and unique than anything out of the mouths of Jay and Nas on their albums.

Illmatic and Reasonable Doubt are really good albums. But, Jay and Nas are just rappers. And by 'just' rappers, I mean... they write rhymes. They write their thoughts, they write little psuedo-stories, they cover topics and themes, but neither of them are really - deeply creative artists. Like Em is a deeply creative artist. People forget it so quickly with Em because of the fact he's done so much introspection now and it's probably what he's most famous for. But The Slim Shady LP is the work of a seriously creative writer and lyricist, much more-so than any other in mainstream hip-hop.