Help with Best of Eminem Mixtape, PLEASE!

[Man In The Mirror]

Hello! Ever sence The Eminem Show came out people don't understand me when I say I love Eminem. They always think I'm into songs like Without Me, Hailies Song, Just Lose It, When I'm Gone and stuff like that. I'm not. Eminem, for me, is something completly different. Now I have collected all his music and I'm trying to do a "Best of Eminem"-mixtape with the runningtime of about 60 to 75 minutes. But there are too much good songs so help me clean the list (and maybe add something I may have forgot) I got so far:
(I think you can tell by the songs what side of Eminem I like the most)

Bad Meets Evil - The Reunion
Bad Meets Evil - Scary Movies
D12 - American Psycho
D12 - Revelation
D12 - Shit On You
Eminem - Watch Deez (with Thirten Howl III)
Dr. Dre - Whats The Difference (with Xzibit & Eminem)
Eminem - What The Beat (with Royce Da 5'9" & Method Man)
Eminem - Chemical Warfare
Yelawolf - Throw It Up (with Eminem & Gangsta Boo)
Biggie - Dead Wrong (with Eminem)
Eminem - Drips (with Obie Trice)
Eminem - When The Music Stops (with D12)
Eminem - Till I Collapse (with Nate Dogg)
Eminem - Love You More
Eminem - Kill You
Eminem - Buffalo Bill
Eminem - Remember Me? (with RBX & Sticky Fingaz)
Eminem - Rock Bottom
Eminem - Bad Meets Evil (with Royce Da 5'9")
Eminem - Still Don't Give A Fuck
Eminem - '97 Bonnie & Clyde
Eminem - I'm Back
Eminem - Role Model
Eminem - Same Song And Dance
Eminem - Marshall Mathers
Eminem - Deja Vu
Eminem - Stay Wide Awake
Eminem - Amityville (with Bizarre)
Eminem - Kim
Eminem - Under The Influence
Eminem - Criminal
Eminem - Going Through Changes

The playtime now are: 2h 26 min.

Are there any songs that are basicly the same so I can remove them for that reason maybe?

[Man In The Mirror]

I really need your help, guys!

[Relapse.]

Add last hit and it will be complete.

[Man In The Mirror]

Add last hit and it will be complete.

Oh! I forgot about that one! thanks man!
Are there some songs that I can remove from the list so the runningtime will be shorter?

[CrashBand]

Definite ones I'd get rid of (in order): Throw It Up , When The Music Stops, Watch Deez, Love You More, Chemical Warfare.

I don't think these hold any weight whatsoever compared to the rest of your list and these other options.

Potential songs to add (no order): Who Knew, Drug Ballad, The Way I Am, Brain Damage, Cleanin' Out My Closet, Say Goodbye To Hollywood, Sing For The Moment, Soldier, Welcome To Hell, Don't Approach Me, Renegade, Forgot About Dre, Lose Yourself, No Apologies, Music Box, On Fire, Cold Wind Blows.

Depending on preferences of course.

Also to make more room perhaps get rid of The Reunion, Under The Influence, Scary Movies and What The Beat.

[Man In The Mirror]

Definite ones I'd get rid of (in order): Throw It Up , When The Music Stops, Watch Deez, Love You More, Chemical Warfare.

I don't think these hold any weight whatsoever compared to the rest of your list and these other options.

Potential songs to add (no order): Who Knew, Drug Ballad, The Way I Am, Brain Damage, Cleanin' Out My Closet, Say Goodbye To Hollywood, Sing For The Moment, Soldier, Welcome To Hell, Don't Approach Me, Renegade, Forgot About Dre, Lose Yourself, No Apologies, Music Box, On Fire, Cold Wind Blows.

Depending on preferences of course.

Also to make more room perhaps get rid of The Reunion, Under The Influence, Scary Movies and What The Beat.

Thank you very much for your help! You gave me many ideas. I replaced Under The Influence with Bitch Please II, because Em's verses on those songs are pretty similar and he only has one verse but I recently started to like Bitch Please II more. I thought of relplacing The Reunion with Welcome 2 Hell but when I thought more of it I like The Reunion just a little bit more. I choose What's The Difference over Forgot About Dre with the same logic as Under The Influence & Bitch Please II. I've made a few more changes so the list is now:

Bad Meets Evil - The Reunion
D12 - American Psycho
D12 - Revelation
D12 - Shit On You
Eminem - Watch Deez (with Thirten Howl III)
Dr. Dre - Whats The Difference (with Xzibit & Eminem)
Eminem - Cleanin' Out My Closet
Eminem - Brain Damage
Yelawolf - Throw It Up (with Eminem & Gangsta Boo)
Biggie - Dead Wrong (with Eminem)
Eminem - Drips (with Obie Trice)
Eminem - When The Music Stops (with D12)
Eminem - Love You More
Eminem - Kill You
Eminem - Buffalo Bill
Eminem - Remember Me? (with RBX & Sticky Fingaz)
Eminem - Who Knew
Eminem - Bad Meets Evil (with Royce Da 5'9")
Eminem - Still Don't Give A Fuck
Eminem - '97 Bonnie & Clyde
Eminem - I'm Back
Eminem - Role Model
Eminem - Same Song And Dance
Eminem - Marshall Mathers
Eminem - Deja Vu
Eminem - Stay Wide Awake
Eminem - Amityville (with Bizarre)
Eminem - Kim
Eminem - Bitch Please II
Eminem - Criminal
Eminem - Going Through Changes
High And Mighty - Last Hit (with Eminem)

The runningtime is still way too long so what I need to do now is remove songs. Many of them. Only recommend songs if it's a really important song. Remember, it's only going to be like 17-20 songs so many favorites is going to be left out.

[CrashBand]

Okay, well with only 20 songs there it will always be very hard to decide.

I think these three would have to be first to go: Throw It Up , When The Music Stops, Love You More.
Followed by these: Watch Deez, Chemical Warfare, Last Hit.

That leaves 25. From there it's pretty difficult.
I would personally knock off
-one of the D12 songs. (very hard decision)
-one out of SSAD and SWA (personally I'd keep Stay Wide Awake)
-Dead Wrong

From there it gets fucking hard. I'd probably sacrifice Remember Me and Drips and Buffalo Bill.

In line with your tastes Drug Ballad could squeeze in the list.

[Man In The Mirror]

Okay, well with only 20 songs there it will always be very hard to decide.

I think these three would have to be first to go: Throw It Up , When The Music Stops, Love You More.
Followed by these: Watch Deez, Chemical Warfare, Last Hit.

That leaves 25. From there it's pretty difficult.
I would personally knock off
-one of the D12 songs. (very hard decision)
-one out of SSAD and SWA (personally I'd keep Stay Wide Awake)
-Dead Wrong

From there it gets fucking hard. I'd probably sacrifice Remember Me and Drips and Buffalo Bill.

In line with your tastes Drug Ballad could squeeze in the list.

Thank you for your help! Well, I'm not going to remove Love You More. I think that song is one of his best up there with Kim and 97 Bonnie & Clyde because of the real emotions and at the same time it's very dark, sick and twisted so I'll keep that one. I think I might add Drug Ballad and remove a couple of the other songs you said.

Okay, so my current list is this:

Bad Meets Evil - The Reunion
D12 - American Psycho
D12 - Shit On You
Eminem - Drug Ballad
Eminem - Cleanin' Out My Closet
Eminem - Brain Damage
Eminem - Drips (feat. Obie Trice)
Eminem - Square Dance
Eminem - Love You More
Eminem - Kill You
Eminem - Buffalo Bill
Eminem - Remember Me? (feat. RBX & Sticky Fingaz)
Eminem - Bad Meets Evil (feat. Royce Da 5'9")
Eminem - Still Don't Give A Fuck
Eminem - '97 Bonnie & Clyde
Eminem - I'm Back
Eminem - Role Model
Eminem - Marshall Mathers
Eminem - Deja Vu
Eminem - Stay Wide Awake
Eminem - Kim
Eminem - Criminal

Now the runningtime is: 1 h 44 minutes, so we need to remove a couple of more songs. The maximum runningtime is 1h 20 minutes for an album/mixtape.
Tell me if i'm really unfair to any song by not having it on his greatest hits. I may change my mind about some songs.

[Man In The Mirror]

Okay, I'm giving up on The Reunion to. It was hard because I fuckin love that song. He slaps bitches, they slap him back, he's trying his best to scare them but it's not working. One of Eminems best topics in a song that is not "serious". And I wanted to keep it because I wanted to have a Bad Meets Evil song on the record to showcase his different projects but then I realized: I already have a Bad Meets Evil-song one here. Is it better than Reunion? Yes. Doesn't I have enough bitch-slapping songs on here? Yes. Does Reunion really deserves a place as top 17-18 best Eminem songs ever? No. I also dropped shit on you..... No I didn't, haha, just had to say it because of the pun. Haha. So now the list is like this:

D12 - American Psycho
D12 - Shit On You
Eminem - Drug Ballad
Eminem - Cleanin' Out My Closet
Eminem - Brain Damage
Eminem - Drips (feat. Obie Trice)
Eminem - Square Dance
Eminem - Love You More
Eminem - Kill You
Eminem - Buffalo Bill
Eminem - Remember Me? (feat. RBX & Sticky Fingaz)
Eminem - Bad Meets Evil (feat. Royce Da 5'9")
Eminem - Still Don't Give A Fuck
Eminem - '97 Bonnie & Clyde
Eminem - I'm Back
Eminem - Role Model
Eminem - Marshall Mathers
Eminem - Deja Vu
Eminem - Stay Wide Awake
Eminem - Kim
Eminem - Criminal

Runningtime: 1 h 39 minutes! We are close, people!

[XxachiganxX]

IMO Get rid of Drips, Square Dance and Still Don't Give A Fuck. Add Soldier and Say Goodbye To Hollywood.

[CrashBand]

Don't get rid of SDGAF.

[Man In The Mirror]

I'll never get rid of Still Don't Give A Fuck, that's my favorit song besides Kim. Drips is awesome, I don't get why people don't like it? I may remove Square Dance. I don't know yet. More suggestions and why you think I should remove sertain songs. Thank for your help!

[12characters]

I'll never get rid of Still Don't Give A Fuck, that's my favorit song besides Kim. Drips is awesome, I don't get why people don't like it? I may remove Square Dance. I don't know yet. More suggestions and why you think I should remove sertain songs. Thank for your help!

[RoleModel'Est96]

I say you get rid of Square Dance.

[Cupid Stunt]

Put On Fire or Underground in there.