bigray wrote:EM should have won MMLP and Recovery for AOTY
Definitely don't think he should have won for
Recovery! - it's a good album with some amazing heights but, nowhere near cohesive or unique enough to be album of the YEAR...
The Marshall Mathers LP... should have ab-so-fucking-lutely won it though. Hands down.
TES was nominated for AOTY too.
It's a bit of a crime he didn't win for MMLP or TES, I doubt he'll ever get a better chance. And both of those I think were album of the year caliber, but MMLP was a defining work that should have.