What ya think about this thread ?

[Rattle1]

http://slumz.boxden.com/f87/does-eminem ... s-1913293/

Most of them are basically saying that Eminem has the worst discography out of the 'G.O.A.T.S'.
They're saying that in years to come his legacy won't be much more than a great technical mc and that his albums didn't age well at all.

I wanted to know your opinion about that because I had no comeback for this.

You should read the other pages, not just the OP.

[Chet Starr]

They rated Encore above Relapse & Recovery

I'm not wasting anymore time with these idiots, that was enough

[Rattle1]

yeah but you should read the other pages, not just the OP

[Chet Starr]

Yeah after reading a few more pages, the people are outrageous stupid

I saw one person call 1 young jeezy album better then all of eminem's catalog

I can't even stand most of Eminem's music, but I still don't agree with those jackels

[King Lance]

I also think that recovery is his worst album, there are some great individual songs but as an album, I think it's average at best but Relapse is better than Encore imo, and it's not even close. Giving this album a 5/10 is a shame

but yeah, as I said before, I also think that Eminem's old albums haven't aged well, particularly the beats on TMMLP but I still call it a classic because of the influence the album had on hip hop 10 years ago

[Chet Starr]

I think all the old pop culture mentions really hurt his albums. Most kids these days probably don't even know who Tom Green or NSYNC is.

It's like a topical south park episode, it's funny at first but It starts fading away when the years pile up.

[Shameek]

I agree with them and I would say that Kanye West is the most consistent rapper, he released 5 masterpieces but he isn't impressive as a rapper.
I love Eminem and he is probably one of the most gifted rappers but I will never put him in my TOP 5/7 of all time, just because of his albums collection.

@Bigray, The blueprint and Reasonable doubt are timeless and classic albums, they are serving as a standard of excellence.

[PAINKILLƎR]

I think it's stupid along with the people who agree with it.

[Shameek]

No one cared about Jay Z in the past until recently...

I never said Reasonable Doubt or Blue Print wasn't dope.

Jay-z was already one of the best rappers in the late 90's and everybody talked about him has a goat tbh

[Shameek]

There were many rappers in the 90s that were better than Jay Z. I don't care if you don't believe me but Jay wasn't that big in the 90s I mean Pac was dissin the fuck out of Jay and he stayed quiet. Puffy was bigger than Jay and had more buzz than Jay.

yeah there were better rappers but most of these rappers didn't make a better album than Reasonable Doubt. A lot of rappers had more buzz than Nas and most of these rappers didn't make a better album than Illmatic.

[Shameek]

Reasonable doubt was a great album I'm not doubting that, I would call it a classic.

yeah and a great technical rapper who doesn't release good albums isn't interesting at all imo, that's why I think that jay-z was one of the greatest rappers back in the days but he isn't consistent at all

[Shameek]

I would call an artist who releases great hip hop albums - songs, a great rapper and I would call an artist who sells a lot of albums a successful rapper lol but jay used to be a great and succesful rapper I guess.

[EminemBase]

Ridiculous.

The wrath of Base is soon to come.

[NotFinished]

Ridiculous.

The wrath of Base is soon to come.

pls...

[Fleka]

Lance5 I don`t agree with you on that "beats haven`t aged well om TMMLP". I like those beats better than most of beats you hear today.