Rank Non-Eminem studio albums

[Shade135]

1) Devil's Night
2) 8 Mile soundtrack
3) Hell: The Sequel
4) The Re-Up
5) Slim Shady EP
6) Refill
7) D12 World
8) Curtain Call

I wouldn't consider putting Refill in this list only because it is barely half an album and can't compete to full length albums.

I think that Devil's Night is even, if not better than Recovery, for a group album that is. Aswell as being on par with Relapse, quality wise.

Re-Up only for No Apologies, Public Enemy #1 and You Don't Know. No Apologies is a very under rated song.

Hell: The Sequel is not a full length album but the awesome-ness of it makes up for that.

Curtain Call is last because I don't think it should be in this list only because it is a greatest hits album with a few new tracks.

D12 World is meh, few good songs.. (How Come and Get My Gun come to mind). This and Curtain Call compete for last place.

8 Mile is second for obvious reasons (Lose Yourself, 8 Mile, Rabbit Run....etc)

Slim Shady EP is better than some but not good enough for the top spots.

[Snakebeast]

LOL @ Snake. Wow you punctuated a point there didn't you. I bagged relapse and you had a fit. I provided my opinion so you went and had your merry way with it nitpicking at everything i said. You said you dont attack people who go against the norm yet what have you done to me?

Not much of a reader, are you? I am arguing with you not because you go against the norm, but because I DISAGREE WITH YOU. Me. PERSONALLY. This has NOTHING to do with the general opinion of TrShady. This is a fucking FORUM. Debate is a thing, didn't you know?

You can't tell me that rap isnt for me. I've been listening to it since the mid 90's. Just because I listen to rap for a different reason to you doesn't mean its wrong, however I am allowed to do this so your opinion on that is completely wrong.

Great. Then maybe current rap isn't for you. Because it sure as hell is way more focused on lyrics than the beat or the hook.

[Wego]

Not much of a reader, are you? I am arguing with you not because you go against the norm, but because I DISAGREE WITH YOU. Me. PERSONALLY. This has NOTHING to do with the general opinion of TrShady. This is a fucking FORUM. Debate is a thing, didn't you know?

The vehemency you display and your flagrant responses however are a direct result of the general opinion on this forum. If the opinion on this board were reversed you wouldn't display like such a jackass.

Maybe put a few more words in capitals to further emphasize your next post.

[Snakebeast]

Not much of a reader, are you? I am arguing with you not because you go against the norm, but because I DISAGREE WITH YOU. Me. PERSONALLY. This has NOTHING to do with the general opinion of TrShady. This is a fucking FORUM. Debate is a thing, didn't you know?

The vehemency you display and your flagrant responses however are a direct result of the general opinion on this forum. If the opinion on this board were reversed you wouldn't display like such a jackass.

Maybe put a few more words in capitals to further emphasize your next post.

I use capitals because you seem incapable of actually reading normal text. Though even that doesn't seem to be working. I can change the size of my font too, if you'd like.

And you have come to the conclusion that this board has heavily influenced my actions....how? Display like a jackass? I'm sorry, picking apart and responding to each part is how this works, isn't it? Now, maybe if you wouldn't ignore anything I say and make random and rather stupid assumptions based on the MERE FACT THAT I RESPONDED TO YOU, I might be a little bit nicer.

[Wego]

Yeah, you were the one who decided you needed to defend the forum from my opinion by belittling me. You're response wouldn't have been as garish had I not been expressing an opinion against the forums.. You were the one who attacked me for having an opinion. You are admitting this after beguiling that you didn't..
After all this it comes down to one point: I expressed my opinion (against the board), you attacked me. This was topic of discussion, of which you so exquisitely proved. One simply cannot have a minority opinion without being unfairly targeted.

[SliK]

I like Wego

[Snakebeast]

Yeah, you were the one who decided you needed to defend the forum from my opinion by belittling me. You're response wouldn't have been as garish had I not been expressing an opinion against the forums.

And....again with the FUCKING assumptions. I am not defending anybody on this forum. As you can see, nobody's stepped in, either. I am arguing with you on the SOLE FACT that I PERSONALLY DISAGREE WITH YOU.

After all this it comes down to one point: I expressed my opinion (against the board), you attacked me. This was topic of discussion, of which you so exquisitely proved. One simply cannot have a minority opinion without being unfairly targeted.

You expressed your opinion. Your opinion is different from mine. And therefore, I decided to pick apart your argument which you provided as a basis for your opinion. This has NOTHING to do with TRShady. Why the fuck would it be? To be blatantly honest, unlike many (or even most) of the people here, I have little to no personal connections to anybody on this forum. I've never even so much as collaborated with another member in CW. So why would I defend anybody?

[Wego]

And....again with the FUCKING assumptions.

You assumed i liked Encore. Then you went on to say all kinds of really mean things about me
cause you're a meanie. You just look like an idiot with your contradictions and double standards.

[Snakebeast]

And....again with the FUCKING assumptions.

You assumed i liked Encore. Then you went on to say all kinds of really mean things about me
cause you're a meanie. You just look like an idiot with your contradictions and double standards.

I didn't assume you liked Encore. I took what you said you looked for in rap music, which was equal parts beat, hook, and lyrics, then applied it to Encore. Encore is lacking in lyrics, but many of the hooks are great (Never Enough is a great example of this) and the beats are all different and interesting (Rainman). 2/3. And Encore had some songs with good lyrics (Spend Some Time, Like Toy Soldiers, etc.). So it's a bit more than 2 out of 3, I guess. Also, props for the Big Weenie reference. Unless you're not joking. Which would be weird.

[4Corners]

All this bickering doesn't change that when someone states their opinion in a way where it comes off as "fact", and if that opinion is against the norm......it's shit on and told they're douche bags, blah blah blah. But when someone states their opinion in a way in comes off as "fact", and they're opinion is the norm............no one calls them out on it.

How people can't see that is beyond me.

I've said simple stuff like I felt that Relapse was uninspiring effort from Em, and that songs like SS&D that are circle jerked around on here were weak, I was then told I didn't know what I was talking about and that Relapse was 100x better than Encore and a classic or near classic.

But when I say Devils Night isn't a classic for various reasons, mainly being it didn't change the game and wasn't anything more than D12's take on MMLP2 and some dope verses from Em, I'm told to shut up and respect peoples opinions, otherwise I'm a loser, douche, etc.

[Wego]

Also, props for the Big Weenie reference. Unless you're not joking. Which would be weird.

Oh, well this is weird. I wasn't joking. And I like Big Weenie.

[Snakebeast]

All this bickering doesn't change that when someone states their opinion in a way where it comes off as "fact", and if that opinion is against the norm......it's shit on and told they're douche bags, blah blah blah. But when someone states their opinion in a way in comes off as "fact", and they're opinion is the norm............no one calls them out on it.

How people can't see that is beyond me.

If that opinion is against MY PERSONAL OPINION, I will "shit on it", as you said. I will argue. I will bicker. Because THAT'S WHAT PEOPLE DO on forums. Nobody ever said anything about the norm. Ever.

Oh, well this is weird. I wasn't joking. And I like Big Weenie.

That song is funny as fuck.......unless you mean actual big weenies. That would be even weirder.

[4Corners]

All this bickering doesn't change that when someone states their opinion in a way where it comes off as "fact", and if that opinion is against the norm......it's shit on and told they're douche bags, blah blah blah. But when someone states their opinion in a way in comes off as "fact", and they're opinion is the norm............no one calls them out on it.

How people can't see that is beyond me.

Oh. My. God. CAN. YOU. NOT. READ?!

If that opinion is against MY PERSONAL OPINION, I will "shit on it", as you said. I will argue. I will bicker. Because THAT'S WHAT PEOPLE DO on forums. Nobody ever said anything about the norm. Ever.

I'm not really talking about you. I only brought up because the Cinderella stan and Ellen guy didn't once call you out for saying Relapse was 1000x better than Recovery just because. You passed that as fact in a post, when it's just an opinion, and they didn't say shit to you.....because that's the norm on here.

But I say Devils Night isn't a classic, no way no how, I'm told I'm a fucking loser and douche bag, etc.

So why was I called out and not you......because your post was the norm on this fucked up place, and mine wasn't.

[Snakebeast]

I'm not really talking about you. I only brought up because the Cinderella stan and Ellen guy didn't once call you out for saying Relapse was 1000x better than Recovery just because. You passed that as fact in a post, when it's just an opinion, and they didn't say shit to you.....because that's the norm on here.

But I say Devils Night isn't a classic, no way no how, I'm told I'm a fucking loser and douche bag, etc.

So why was I called out and not you......because your post was the norm on this fucked up place, and mine wasn't.

I'm pretty sure they didn't call me out on it because they agreed with me. On the other hand, if someone like Mr. Change read it, I'm sure he'd at least say something to the contrary if he was feeling particularly confrontational. And tell me who called you a fucking loser and douchebag for thinking Devil's Night isn't a classic. I'm pretty sure someone like that would've been banned by now (class is an exception doe, not sure what the mods are doin with that one). I've been in plenty of arguments regarding Recovery vs Relapse. We are individuals, not just one giant hive mind with one opinion. We all have our own reasons for liking Relapse over Recovery, and vice versa.

[4Corners]

^ Nah, you come off as a know-it-all cunt, is all.

"But so do you menzo!!"

This from the guy who states no one who matters thinks Beautiful is a great song.