Would you rather...

[Ottawa613]

Ok. Pretend it's late 2014 / early 2015. You get a choice for the next Eminem album: a new solo album or an album of previously unreleased and unheard tracks from 1999-2008.

Just to expand on each:

the new album would have 14 songs and 4 skits. Three bonus tracks.
the unheard album would have 18 songs

[TRickster]

Well this is easy, the new album full of new material, the songs from 1999-2008 might not even b all that great, there is a reason to why he hasn't released them, think "Wee Wee".

[Kill You]

New solo album, very easily actually.

[yoda you can call me]

New stuff. I prefer to see growth than going back over old stuff that he deemed not good to put out

[TRickster]

1999 - 2003 come on dude there's no wee wee in that era and im sure he's got some locked up that are dope.

tupac had countless songs locked up that were dope af and he still does.

Yes but there is no garuntee that the songs from 1999-2003 are great & dont wanna take any chances when we could get another classic album like the current one we are gonna be receiving.

[TRickster]

the album isn't even out yet and you're calling it a classic he had 3 b4 that why were they not classics?

anyway they could be on par with sslp, mmlp and tes, we dont know.

It's called opinions & yes judging by the songs we recently received I can say that it will top the first 3 albums already, without Survival, adding it kinda dumbed it down to Encore level, but Rap God came out & I could tell that this could be on the level of the first 3 albums combined.

Alright maybe I'm over the edge here a bit maybe NOT on par with MMLP but it has potential.

[JORDANM]

unheard eminem material, would like to hear what songs got replaced for drips

[BILI]

Depends on how good MMLP2 is...if its on some Recovery bullshit Id go for unheard...if its in his top 3,4 Id go for new material

[Kill You]

Survival >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Encore lol. Than every single Encore song. Except maybe Love You More, that's it.

[kkaniff]

What BILI said.

[monobloss]

Survival >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Encore lol. Than every single Encore song. Except maybe Love You More, that's it.

What about Like toy soldiers, mockingbird, yellow brick road, evil deeds > survival imo.

[2PointOBoy]

No brainer for me: unheard material. Even if there's 1 song from 2001-2002, I KNOW it'll be DOPE, plus that era is my favorite & I'd love to get anything from that period.

[yoda you can call me]

1999 - 2003 come on dude there's no wee wee in that era and im sure he's got some locked up that are dope.

tupac had countless songs locked up that were dope af and he still does.

Yes but there is no garuntee that the songs from 1999-2003 are great & dont wanna take any chances when we could get another classic album like the current one we are gonna be receiving.

i hate it when people say mmlp2 is gonna be a classic. feels like you're jinxing it.. thats why i won't even allow myself to think that.. that'll be the stan in me, no doubt