MMLP2 REVIEWS

[ZinedinOS]

BTW: MMLP2 has been added to Metacritic; two reviews are included for now, Rolling Stone and Spin. Both are an 80/100. Four reviews have to be included for an average rating, so we don't have one yet. I'd post a link, but for some reason I can't. Perhaps because I'm a new user?

Yes, 3 more posts and you'll be able to do that

Yaay!

[Mr Change]

Well, this guy reviewed 2 singles:


I like this guy, because he reviews all types of music, but, I disagree with some things he said about these tracks.

But, it's all good.

I love theneedledrop but I dread his review...

*talks good about the album for 10 minutes* "I'm feeling a light 5 out of 10"

[mdemaz]

He usually hits the nail on the head most of the time when it comes to reviews, though.

I'm pretty sure he's heard the whole album in full and he's jizzed himself.

Lol at all of those idiotic comments.

[yoda you can call me]

http://www.usatoday.com/story/life/musi ... -review/33 good review

[Sofi1993]

Artistdirect – 5/5 stars

Rolling Stone – 4/5 stars

New York Daily News – 4/5 stars

Vice (Noisey) – acclaim (no score)

Spin – 8/10

Los Angeles Times – 3/4 stars

USA Today – 3.5/4 stars

ABC 12 – acclaim (no score)

[Trimss]

That USAtoday link doesn't work for me..

Anyway, Rolling Stones gave MBDTF and Channel Orange a 4/5 too.

[_Hawk_]

No, they didn't Trimms.

Rolling Stone gave MBDTF a solid 5.

[One Mic]

Digital Spy gave it 4/5 stars http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/music/revie ... rdict.html

you should edit the op and link to all the reviews and their ratings etc

[Trimss]

No, they didn't Trimms.

Rolling Stone gave MBDTF a solid 5.

Oh yeah, you're right about MBDTF. I don't know why I included it in, but I was right about CO. It really got a 4/5 and is considered as one of the best album of this decade.

http://www.rollingstone.com/music/album ... e-20120713

[_Hawk_]

I think MMLP2 deserves a 4.5 from Rolling Stone.

They don't justify the rating.

[_Hawk_]

When Em drops the Encore 2, this album will zoom up.

[Monroe19]

getting amazing reviews.so deserving !

[EriCartman]

Fuck critics man...

You know the one thing I noticed about critics man..

Is , they never ask me how my day went ...

[Kill You]

getting amazing reviews.so deserving !

Because even shitty critics appreciate great music.

[_Hawk_]

Can someone update the 'Critical Reception' section on the wiki page to say 'Upon release, the MMLP2 achieved rave reviews/universal acclaim/overwhelmingly positive responses from musical critics..."?

I hate how biased Wiki articles can be against Eminem
Go on Kanye's album pages, and any of his with metacritic scores of 80 + have the above write-ups, yet Em's just say 'generally positive'.