MMLP2 REVIEWS

[Iris2]

I'm not the biggest Kanye fan, so I've never been able to understand how a hip hop album with shitty lyrics or average at best lyrics could be a hip hop classic.

You have to focus on the production and the overall sound of the album. I guess it's diverse and grand considering it's a rap album.

[BILI]

I thought there was a fair bit of filler/uninteresting lines on the album.

The pitchfork review kind of sums up how I feel, but I'd rate this album a little higher than they did.

Well thats because your music taste sucks..

Are you still upset that I said MBDTF and gkmc are better than MMLP2?

If you think that's bad taste in music then you're a moron.

Nah not at all...if you read that thread you would actually see that I also said GKMC>>MMLP2...but I still laugh at that MBDTF...worst album ever to be called great...come on "Do you fools listen to music or do you just skim through it" cause those lyrics on that album are something a 10 year olds could write

[SliK]

he doesn't have to enjoy whatever is praised by the critics

I honestly don't care what he likes, why would I?

He's obviously got some issue with Kanye and cannot process the fact that people prefer Kanye's music to Eminem's. That's really his not my problem, so singling me out and attacking me because I don't have exactly the same taste in music is completely moronic.

So maybe you should be directing that statement towards him.

[4Corners]

I'm not the biggest Kanye fan, so I've never been able to understand how a hip hop album with shitty lyrics or average at best lyrics could be a hip hop classic.

You have to focus on the production and the overall sound of the album. I guess it's diverse and grand considering it's a rap album.

The production is great, but I don't care how great it is if what he's saying sounds like ass.

[2PointOBoy]

What did Pitchfork say that was unreasonable?

The rating most of all..

[SliK]

What did Pitchfork say that was unreasonable?

The rating most of all..

Yeah I thought it was underrated by about 1.8. Obviously they were a little harsher on it that I was but this alb is no classic.

[Iris2]

I'm not the biggest Kanye fan, so I've never been able to understand how a hip hop album with shitty lyrics or average at best lyrics could be a hip hop classic.

You have to focus on the production and the overall sound of the album. I guess it's diverse and grand considering it's a rap album.

The production is great, but I don't care how great it is if what he's saying sounds like ass.[/quote]
That's your take on music. Some people believe the production on the album is good enough to bring it to new highs and make a listener ignore the lyrics. Obviously, the album has an overall attitude that people can sit back and enjoy. No one can take anything away from that.

[kkaniff]

Personally, I think any review rating less than a 7/10 is terribly wrong.

[kkaniff]

Also, anybody who rates Yeezus more than a point above MMLP 2 is an idiot.

[BILI]

he doesn't have to enjoy whatever is praised by the critics

I honestly don't care what he likes, why would I?

He's obviously got some issue with Kanye and cannot process the fact that people prefer Kanye's music to Eminem's. That's really his not my problem, so singling me out and attacking me because I don't have exactly the same taste in music is completely moronic.

So maybe you should be directing that statement towards him.

Nah I have nothing against Kanye...his 1st 3 albums are great in my book...I even love 808s...only dislike yeezus so far tbh...and dont get me wrong I also like MBDTF...its just not soooooooo fucking great as some make it out to be...now that thats said...I hate Ye stans (not Kanyes music)...they are almost as bad if not worse then weezy stans...annoying as fuck...just look at some threads...spamming every thread with Kanye and turning it into Ye vsEm...there is Kanye forum down the block...go there...I dont go around web bitching on sites/forums for artists I dont like...I like Em Im on Em forum...I like Led Zeppelin Im on Led Zeppelin forum


Why should he direct this statement to me

he doesn't have to enjoy whatever is praised by the critics

Its obvious you actually enjoy what critics praise and I dont...

[SliK]

I'm talking about MMLP2 which is getting generally positive reviews.

[BILI]

I'm talking about MMLP2 which is getting generally positive reviews.

Well for all I care it can get all 10/10s or 0/10s...I still think its a great album..not a classic and not a huge game changer but one of the better albums this year...at the end of it all this year sucked so it wasnt that hard to beat it. I would give this album a solid 7.5 maybe 8/10.

Now pls be honest and tell me if this is better then MMLP2, Ill be honest...I only heard 3 songs from that album like 10 days ago so basically I shouldnt judge it till I hear it whole ( which I wont) but cmon...
http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/182 ... ch-niggas/

[EminemBase]

"""Earlier in his career, Eminem delivered similarly gutbucket content with the shock of incredulity that anyone would find it offensive. It was an error of youthful carelessness""""

Seriously... how the FUCK do these people have jobs!?

'an error'? LMAO.

No it was fucking intentional provocation!!

I'm gobsmacked right now. Guys, what the fuck is going on? How can so many people not get something so fucking simple. I swear it's just fucking America. Jesus.

[4Corners]

AllMusic 4/5
http://www.allmusic.com/blog/post/emine ... thers-lp-2

[kkaniff]

^ It's almost criminal, man. Like they put in absolutely no effort whatsoever, and what's worse is they won't get called out on it.