Mr Change wrote:TRshady: Recovery
Everywhere else: Encore
If MMLP2 gets mixed reviews when it's all said and done: MMLP2
It won't. Half of underrated or overrated is up to critics. MMLP2 has already gotten his best critical response since MMLP, equal with TES. Though it's not nearly as great as TES obviously.
The fan response seems to be a variety of these....
Eminem will never sound the same as before, but it's still good.
His best album in years.
His best and most confident rapping since Eminem Show.
Way better than his last three, not nearly as good as his first three though.
Still can't match his first three, it was decent, I expected more though.
Considering it's not getting 50% or more complete hate, like his last three did right away, I'd say it's been well received by critics and fans alike.