MMLP2 is NOT a classic.

[Rattle1]

To me an album is classic if most people call it a classic. Ask people to give you 5 classics for this decade and you can be sure that nobody will mention mmlp2

http://www.thecoli.com/threads/if-you-c ... 176/page-3

http://slumz.boxden.com/f87/if-you-coul ... y-2007803/

http://www.kanyetothe.com/forum/index.p ... c=592441.0

When fans talk about recent classic albums, they all mention the same shit:

MBDTF, GKMC, Take Care, Lig, S80, Undun, OB4CL2(Raekwon), Return of Forever (Big Krit), XXX

[kkaniff]

Dunno about The Coli, but I was pretty regular on Bx 'till I got perma-banned, majority of the votes on the MMLP2 poll says it's 4/5. The next most popular opinion is 5/5 or classic.
KTT are a bunch of pre-pubescent psedo-hipster faggots and as such their opinions don't matter.

[kkaniff]

Also whoever says Take Care is a classic should be neutered.

[Rattle1]

The classic status of an album is termined by the masses though.

nobody's opinion should mean shit to the next person BUT classics are pretty much agreed upon by the majority and widely accepted as classics.

Also whoever says Take Care is a classic should be neutered.

As much as I hate take care, theres no denying that this shit will become a classic.

[sbolli1]

Also whoever says Take Care is a classic should be neutered.

[Rattle1]

the album is not acclaimed at all tbh, I haven't seen a single person talking about it as a classic.

[Kill You]

the album is not acclaimed at all tbh, I haven't seen a single person talking about it as a classic.

What? Lol. It is acclaimed.

[Steelez]

the album is not a classic and it doesn't have the potential to become one, it is just another good/great album of the 2010s

[kkaniff]

Again, ^ this.

[Rattle1]

lol I'm not only talking about internet, nobody is calling that album a classic

[VINTAGƎ]

I think it's too early to determine whether or not this is a classic, but it's a solid album, and I enjoy it, so that's all that matters to me. No, I don't get the same fuzzy feeling as I did with his first three, but that very well could be the nostalgia I feel for them.

Anyway, this is what annoys me about rap. People think the "competitive" nature of it is good. I think in some ways it is and some ways it's not. I'm so tired of people saying x album is better than x album. X artist has a better discography than x artist, etc.

I don't see that in any other genre. I mostly listen to rock, and when I talk music with my rock friends, that shit never comes up. We don't say oh Led Zeppelin is better than The Beatles because they have more "certified classics" etc. You just say you like Led Zeppelin more because you like their sound more. But you can appreciate The Beatles. You don't hear shit about "top 5 bands dead or alive."

Everything in rap has to be a fucking contest between two artists. It's annoying. No album is objectively better than another. I think MBDTF is extremely overrated, a mediocre album at best, and Yeezus is electronica Encore. That's my personal opinion. I don't care if MBDTF is considered a classic among the hip hop community. I have my own opinion.

Same with Eminem. If people largely considered this a classic, or largely considered it a dud, I would still say this is a solid album because to me, that's what it is. I don't care what other people have to say about it.

[Accor]

i'm sure plenty of people called mmlp a classic lol

[Rattle1]

A "Classic" album is one that stands out and I don't even see mmlp2 as the best rap album of the year


You crazy StayWideAwake, everybody was calling that album a top 5 album of all time.

[kasia]

I think it's way too early to even debate if it's a classic or not. It's still new and fresh. We'll see in a few years, I guess. I don't think MMLP was called a classic right from the start lol.

[kkaniff]

"Yeezus was given more
universal praise than MMLP at release"
By far.