Which Album.

[ctodap]

Bren08 Posted: Sat Apr 14, 2007 12:33 am
well..the Re-Up is fresh and good material but the songs in Curtain Call are better than songs in Re-Up, for a person who just got to listen to eminem I would recommend curtain call.

same for me

[theJuSt]

wtf ? u cant compare a greatest hits abum to a compilation album man.

[sudhanshueminem]

yo re up is a cre fight.in dat album we can listen 2 many rappers....

but curtain call consisted of old hits only 3 were new
curtain call is better dan reup coz it has sum of eminem's best songs

[DrRapid]

also in da re-up they have remixes so not everything is new shit

i didn't like jimmy crack corn

[shady_aftermathzz]

i can't believe ppl' going for re-up instead of the curtain call
they can't be compared, the curtain call by far/ whats wrong with u ppl?

[slimtrop1]

RE UP

[4D]

On the weight of the tracks, it'd have to be curtain call. But at the same time, I was looking forward to The Re-Up more than CC, because it had more new stuff on it than CC did. And I hate greatest hits albums, they suck because it's always just the singles on the album. Best Of's are a much better way to see the greatest songs of an artist.

So, the songs are better on Curtain Call, but because there was none of his unreleased classics on it, I`m gonna vote for The Re-Up out of protest.

[sudhanshueminem]

yo ppl try 2 understand curtain hits has all da best songs of eminem till 2005 and reup is just a compilation album....der r more remixes dan new songs in reup

[4D]

yo ppl try 2 understand curtain hits has all da best songs of eminem till 2005 and reup is just a compilation album....der r more remixes dan new songs in reup

No it doesn't, it only has the best songs that he released. What about "Infinite", "Never Too Far", "open Mic", "Till Hell Freezes Over", "Murder Murder", "Rock Bottom", "97 Bonnie & Clyde", "Our House", "Marshall Mathers", "Kim", "The Sauce", Quitter", "Square Dance", "Haileys Song", "Till I Collapse", "Renegade", "We As Americans".

Thought you said it had all of his best songs up to 2005? It didn't.

A 2 or 3 disc "Best Of EMinem" collection, would have been much better value for money.

[DrRapid]

yo ppl try 2 understand curtain hits has all da best songs of eminem till 2005 and reup is just a compilation album....der r more remixes dan new songs in reup

No it doesn't, it only has the best songs that he released. What about "Infinite", "Never Too Far", "open Mic", "Till Hell Freezes Over", "Murder Murder", "Rock Bottom", "97 Bonnie & Clyde", "Our House", "Marshall Mathers", "Kim", "The Sauce", Quitter", "Square Dance", "Haileys Song", "Till I Collapse", "Renegade", "We As Americans".

Thought you said it had all of his best songs up to 2005? It didn't.

A 2 or 3 disc "Best Of EMinem" collection, would have been much better value for money.

yep that's true
there was some stuff on CC like My Name Is which i would have replaced for Rock Bottom