FACK could have been decent

[Tash8]

you know if eminem didn't rap on that beat, and just put the beat on his tape it would have been way better

[joelle]

The first thing I did when I heard the song was think, "Hailie's gonna be scarred for life when she hears this."
The second thing I did was laugh.
It wasn't one of the greatest tracks of all time, and it probably shouldn't have been on Curtain Call. But I think it achieved what it set out to do: entertain. Not every song is supposed to make you be like "DAMN, THATS DEEP AS HELL, I HAVE A NEW LIFE OUTLOOK NOW." That'd take away from the songs that actually do that. But it's a song that made me laugh. And I think that's just as important as a song that makes you think.

[Tash8]

no it wasn't funny, it was disgusting.. eminem can be funny he has plenty songs where he is funny, THIS was not one of them..

[D0llyShady]

I also don't think it's funny. Rather lame.
I agree with joelle that some songs don't have to have a meaning, it's cool if some make you laugh and you can't stop laughing everytime you hear it, but 'Fack' isn't one of them. It's only lame and nothing more. At least for me.

[4D]

no it wasn't funny, it was disgusting.. eminem can be funny he has plenty songs where he is funny, THIS was not one of them..

Well, you need a sense of humour. It wasn't the content that was funny for me, it was the delivery. The bit where he says, "Okay I'm done, I already came twice, You ain't gonna make me cum, I'm all out of gas, not so fast, AH, your finger just went in my ass!", that is fuckin laugh out loud funny, just the way he says it.

It's a matter of taste, or lack of, lol.

[Tash8]

no it wasn't funny, it was disgusting.. eminem can be funny he has plenty songs where he is funny, THIS was not one of them..

Well, you need a sense of humour. It wasn't the content that was funny for me, it was the delivery. The bit where he says, "Okay I'm done, I already came twice, You ain't gonna make me cum, I'm all out of gas, not so fast, AH, your finger just went in my ass!", that is fuckin laugh out loud funny, just the way he says it.

It's a matter of taste, or lack of, lol.

maybe the voice was funny, but i don't know it's not funny, i got a sense of humor believe me, but this was not funny.. this was fuckin stupid ass song, and just admit it he did it trying to be funny.. i've noticed eminem always tries to be funny but sometimes he's not, this was jsut one of them..

he either did it to show he doesn't give a fuck or he was tryin to be funny.

[joelle]

ahh, funny is a matter of opinion.
So is depth, so is good delivery, so is substance. A song is how the listener perceives it and nothing more or less.

[4D]

no it wasn't funny, it was disgusting.. eminem can be funny he has plenty songs where he is funny, THIS was not one of them..

Well, you need a sense of humour. It wasn't the content that was funny for me, it was the delivery. The bit where he says, "Okay I'm done, I already came twice, You ain't gonna make me cum, I'm all out of gas, not so fast, AH, your finger just went in my ass!", that is fuckin laugh out loud funny, just the way he says it.

It's a matter of taste, or lack of, lol.

maybe the voice was funny, but i don't know it's not funny, i got a sense of humor believe me, but this was not funny.. this was fuckin stupid ass song, and just admit it he did it trying to be funny.. i've noticed eminem always tries to be funny but sometimes he's not, this was jsut one of them..

he either did it to show he doesn't give a fuck or he was tryin to be funny.

ahh, funny is a matter of opinion.
So is depth, so is good delivery, so is substance. A song is how the listener perceives it and nothing more or less.

[BabyBLue91]

iii think its so stupid & gross.. that it actually became funny in its own sick way
thats eminem for ya..

[Hadez]

he either did it to show he doesn't give a fuck.

that whole idea is stupid. he had 4 albums on how he doesn't give a fuck. he doesn't need one song to do it.

i see 3 different people in this thread and every other thread about this song.... the hardcore fans that are just finding an excuse to listen to the song (i.e. "the song is just so damn funny!", i dont mean you 4D ). then the people who are legit and don't like the song. last you got the same hardcore fans picking apart the song every possible way in fear of being called a groupie for liking a stupid song.

[joelle]

..^ seems like you're saying you're only legit if you don't like the song.

[Tash8]

that whole idea is stupid. he had 4 albums on how he doesn't give a fuck. he doesn't need one song to do it.

i see 3 different people in this thread and every other thread about this song.... the hardcore fans that are just finding an excuse to listen to the song (i.e. "the song is just so damn funny!", i dont mean you 4D ). then the people who are legit and don't like the song. last you got the same hardcore fans picking apart the song every possible way in fear of being called a groupie for liking a stupid song.

why did u just decide to pick one comment of mine, while i've been argueing this whole time on how this song was just stupid

i think it was a gay song no matter what, funny or not, it was gay...

[Hadez]

^^^ my first statement was about what i quoted. the second statement was just a general observation of this thread and others, had nothin to do with you're post.


at joelle - the first two people are legit, the 1st becuz they come out n say they like it. the 2nd becuz they say they dont like it and mean it. i said the word "legit" in comparisson to the 3rd person.

[jBouchh]

i agree with tash a lot. eminem is a funny character, listen to his prank calls. this on the other hand, wasnt. the song was bearable till the gerbil part. i dont think that part was funny at all.

[Tash8]

at joelle - the first two people are legit, the 1st becuz they come out n say they like it. the 2nd becuz they say they dont like it and mean it. i said the word "legit" in comparisson to the 3rd person.

mine's not legit because ...?