"Dear Marshall" by Debbie

[joelle]

....yeah. It was on a CD his mom made. She talked about it countless places, including on the Sally Raphael (or wtv her name is) show. And that line from Cleanin out my Closet refers to "Dear Marshall" and the cd.

[BabyBLue91]

lmao @ the "eye color debate"



^^juss wanted to post & laugh @ that to be honest .

but since i gotta stay on tha topic, thats his personal life & she'll always be his mother no matter what he'll always have love for her even if she did fuck him over, wished death upon him, kicked him out & made him suffer countless number of times

[Tash8]

the reason people are soo into eminem's personal life, not trying to be groupie or anything here, but it's because he tells it ro us... in his songs, he's always telling us about his personal life, and it's like a story and he never told us the ending...

[BabyBLue91]

tru dat

[macdaddy019967]

the reason people are soo into eminem's personal life, not trying to be groupie or anything here, but it's because he tells it ro us... in his songs, he's always telling us about his personal life, and it's like a story and he never told us the ending...

Yea true that and we are never going to stop listening to his music till he does give us an ending

[joelle]

^even then, why would we stop? We'll always have his music

[beardhomestead]

^ that who did what? that Debbie wrote this?

My whole life I was made to believe I was sick when I wasn't/
Til I grew up now I blew up it makes you sick to your stomach/
Doesn't it, wasn't it the reason you made that CD for me Ma?/
So you could try to justify the way you treated me Ma?

wow, as soon as I clicked page 2 that line started on my computer lol

and this eye color debate is funny as fuck lol

[Inzanity]

wow all the arguing over his eye color honestly who care's wat color eye's he has. Anyway, my opinion on the song is that it's a good way to hear her side of the story. Most people are gonna take Eminem's side just cuz' he's famous and rich now I'm not saying I'm on her side but I think people should hear both side's of the story before they start judging.

[Robbie G]

I think its bull, but who knows?

[joelle]

If people still can't understand why I brought up his eye color, there's nothing else to say.

And yeah it's ok to hear both sides of the story...except when one half has Munchausen's Syndrome, aka lives to lie. And what did Em gain by making a song like COMC, except to get shit off his chest? He was already rich by that point, he didn't need the money..what else did have to gain by completely making all of that up? What he says makes sense. What Debbie says doesn't.

^btw, Proof didn't die in 2008...?