do you believe murder is ever "acceptable"?

[Mr. Chambers]

and yes...i know theres self defence...but i mean i guess in a way revenge....like is there certain instances and cases where the murder of one human can be excused due to an event or events? and if so what do you think some cases are that would pardon the murderer from committing the act?

or do you believe in all cases murder is wrong...and any wrong doing should be handled by authority?


i dunno if this was ever posted...but i'm not searching.....

[Emadyville]

well i think self-defense is fine, i think if someone killed someones family member or friend etc, and they went and killed the person that's also acceptable in my eyes, and also if someone kills someone else who is just scum, I also think that's acceptable. for instance, bernie madoff, as a human being what he did is just disgusting, so if someone killed him i would hope they would never go to jail.

just my thoughts

[Sophie]

no....and that includes people giving the death penalty...wtf gives them the right to deserve who dies? (and i know the law, but the law is fucked up in itself) that just makes them as bad as them imo..also death is an easy way out for a murderer/someone on death row..but okay i'm going slightly off topic. but basically..no..i don't think murder is ever acceptable..sure, if someone killed my family/friends i'd wanna kill them..but that just makes me as bad as them & i'd never actually do it.

i think instead of something like the death penalty, they should do something like they did in a clockwork orange, make them watch his crimes that he commited..that's much better.

self defense is a whole different scenario, depending on what the crime is at the time etc...but i still think that doesn't justify it.

[Tornado]

Yeh, i feel murder is acceptable, i don't advocate it but someone close got murdered and i knew the fucker, i'd be thinking to myself "what kind of coward am i to let them get away with it" and unless someone can stop me, i'll atleast try.Emotion is stronger than we believe and fuck this "what gives us the right " shit. There's a lot of examples of which i can say "what gives us the right"...that no one cares about. Don't wana get murdered, dont give no one a reason to.

With self defense, if you attack me, if you get killed,you bought it on yourself

[DrunkenDeath]

today i picked up a magazine while sitting down. they talked about how tragic it is that thousands of people died in 9/11 and how thousands of american soldiers died in the war. they didn't mention the thousands of people who lived in iraq dying.


a TV commercial spreading the word about land mines from past wars going off and killing people in several countries, and how expensive it is to unset them without it blowing up. they showed it happening with american actors during a soccer game. a land mine blew up, and at the end they gave the short documentary about how it should stop and please donate money. When the TV commercial was going through the process of approval, it was banned because it showed americans dying. you can find it on youtube or somewhere else.

[Solace]

Yeh, i feel murder is acceptable, i don't advocate it but someone close got murdered and i knew the fucker, i'd be thinking to myself "what kind of coward am i to let them get away with it" and unless someone can stop me, i'll atleast try.Emotion is stronger than we believe and fuck this "what gives us the right " shit. There's a lot of examples of which i can say "what gives us the right"...that no one cares about. Don't wana get murdered, dont give no one a reason to.

With self defense, if you attack me, if you get killed,you bought it on yourself

That.

[BabyBLue91]

No i dont believe murder is ever 'acceptable' even if they took my family member away.. theyll eventually get whats coming to them, and i believe if theyre alive theyll suffer more.. karma never seems to fail & is always a bitch. I also dont believe in the death penalty but thats another subject

[DrunkenDeath]

Murder has been accepted several times before, or they get off the hook. but usually only when the killer is diagnosed with certain mental disorders. other than that, it's probably happened.

but in america, it doesn't matter who you are or what happened to you.. unless you're famous or work for the government in a high power in some way, if you murder, people will hate you and you'll be in jail for a while. or forever.

[Arabian Shady]

No i dont believe murder is ever 'acceptable' even if they took my family member away.. theyll eventually get whats coming to them, and i believe if theyre alive theyll suffer more.. karma never seems to fail & is always a bitch. I also dont believe in the death penalty but thats another subject

i think that as well


Also looking from a different perspective, what if the family member deserved to die , say he rape the murderers sister, is your "revenge" justified?

[RapName]

and yes...i know theres self defence...but i mean i guess in a way revenge....like is there certain instances and cases where the murder of one human can be excused due to an event or events? and if so what do you think some cases are that would pardon the murderer from committing the act?

or do you believe in all cases murder is wrong...and any wrong doing should be handled by authority?


i dunno if this was ever posted...but i'm not searching.....

If someone really hurt my daughter, i would have no problem in ending that guys life. thats all i got to say. it may not be acceptable, but for my its the right thing to do in that situation.

[emzee-frenzy]

Murder as revenge is not that effective, because the guy who did something very bad to you is now dead, so he doesn't feel any pain, he didn't get what he deserved. So i prefer beating up (unless you have something up your sleeve in his own emotional life), as eminem said "and it's actually better 'cause instead of you murdering you can hit 'em and come back again and kick dirt at 'em"
But anyway, i'm really not that into revenge when it comes to everyday things, like being bullied, cheated on, taken advantage of in general, even tough i hate it, i usually just say "Fuck it, let 'em wait, i'm smarter than them and i'ma be a lot more than they would ever be in this life"
But for instance, if someone would of killed somebody close to me, well that fucker is getting it, and what i'ma do to him is a lot worse than death, i'ma leave him traumatized till he ends up in a fucking mental institution.

[Wic Kid]

Well, if someone killed or hurt my family, I'd go far beyond committing murder. Torture and shit. And that murder is acceptable IMO. Even if its not, that shouldnt be reason not to revenge.

[Xray]

Eye for an eye is acceptable in my books. Lot of people deserve to be murdered. Killing an innocent just for fun or something like that is pointless and sickening. Someone that's been pushing on your buttons for a while deserves to be murdered, the question is, are you willing to go to jail for it?

We all know if laws didn't exist everyone would want to kill everyone simply because there's no law to fight it. But since there is a law, people don't want to go to jail so they remain patient. Simple as that, although there's a lot of people who haven't got the patience so they kill the person that's been pushing their buttons, and I find that acceptable.

[Sophie]

Oh and some of you said 'What gives them the right?' , well what gave the murderer the right?

nothing gave the murderer the right, but two wrongs don't make a right

[kalbird]

From ma point of view,its totally unacceptable nomatter watt!